Animals and Crop Production: Types of Interactions

Last updated: October 05, 2026

1. Introduction: Why Crop Production Is Impossible Without Animals

At first glance, crop production may seem like an exclusively “plant” discipline. However, from an ecological point of view, agrocenosis is not simply a field sown with cultivated plants. It is a complex, dynamic ecosystem in which plants are only one component, albeit a key one. A full understanding and management of such a system is impossible without taking into account its animal population — the zoocenosis. Ignoring the role of animals in the agrocenosis not only impoverishes our understanding of it but also leads to serious mistakes in agronomic decisions, reduced yields, and soil degradation.

Agrocenosis as an Ecosystem

Modern agroecology views an agricultural field as an anthropogenically modified ecosystem. According to the definition, an agroecosystem is “an agricultural system understood as an ecosystem” (Gliessman, 2007). This means that all fundamental ecological laws, including energy flow, nutrient cycling, and — especially important for us — the network of trophic (food) interactions, also operate here. Plants in this system act as primary producers, creating organic matter. However, the further fate of this matter, its transformation, return to the soil, and availability to subsequent generations of plants directly depend on the activity of heterotrophic organisms, primarily animals and microorganisms.

Functional Groups of Animals in the Agrosphere

Animals in an agrocenosis do not merely “inhabit” it. They perform a number of critically important ecological functions, which can be conventionally divided into several groups:

1. Pollinators: They ensure sexual reproduction and yield formation in most entomophilous (insect-pollinated) crops. Without them, the existence of sectors such as horticulture, melon growing, and seed production of many crops would be impossible (Garibaldi et al., 2013; IPBES, 2016).

2. Phytophages (herbivores): They consume plant biomass. In the context of an agrocenosis, they are most often regarded as pests, but their role is not limited to causing damage. They are primary consumers, transferring energy and matter from the plant link to the animal link, making them available to predators and parasitoids (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

3. Entomophages and predators: They regulate the abundance of phytophages, performing the function of natural biological control. Predatory and parasitic insects, spiders, birds, and mammals are the “sanitarians” of the agrocenosis, restraining outbreaks of pest reproduction (Pedigo, 2002; Shameer & Hardy, 2024).

4. Detritivores and soil fauna: They decompose dead organic matter and participate in the formation of soil structure and nutrient cycling. Earthworms, enchytraeids, springtails, mites, and many other invertebrates turn plant residues into humus, making nutrients again available to plants (Coleman et al., 2004; Weil & Brady, 2017).

5. Zoochores (seed dispersers): They promote plant dispersal, which is important both for wild species and, in some cases, for cultivated ones (Godó et al., 2022).

6. Disease vectors: They transmit phytopathogenic organisms — viruses, bacteria, mycoplasmas — from diseased plants to healthy ones, which is one of the key problems in plant protection (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017).

7. Ecosystem engineers: Animals that actively change the physical habitat, creating, modifying, or maintaining habitats for other organisms. Earthworms, ants, and termites are clear examples of such activity (Weil & Brady, 2017; Straalen, 2023).

Why Ignoring Animals Leads to Mistakes

A simplified, “plant-centered” view of the agrocenosis has historically led to a number of problems. Intensive monoculture, destruction of natural habitats, and uncontrolled use of pesticides are all results of ignoring the complexity of ecological connections. For example, destroying insect pests with broad-spectrum pesticides often led to the destruction of their natural enemies, which caused even stronger pest outbreaks in subsequent generations (Pedigo, 2002). Reducing the agrocenosis to a “factory” for producing yield destroys the functional biodiversity that underlies the stability and resilience of the system.

Thus, for effective and sustainable management of an agrocenosis, it is necessary to move from simply dividing animals into “beneficial” and “harmful” to understanding the entire complex network of their interactions with plants and with one another. This lecture is devoted precisely to this task — forming a holistic understanding of the diversity of interactions between animals and cultivated plants.

2. Classification of Animal–Plant Interactions

After we have become convinced that an agrocenosis cannot be understood without animals, it is necessary to organize our knowledge about exactly how animals and plants interact with each other. For this, ecology has several classification systems. The most fundamental and widely used is the classification of interactions by their sign — that is, by what influence (positive, negative, or neutral) the interaction has on each participant.

Interactions by Sign

This system, first proposed in expanded form by E. P. Odum (Odum, 1971) and described in detail in works on agroecology (Gliessman, 2007), considers the interaction of two organisms (or groups of organisms) as a combination of effects: “+” (positive effect, improvement of survival, growth, or reproduction), “−” (negative effect, worsening of these indicators), or “0” (neutral effect, absence of significant influence).

Let us consider the main types of such interactions as applied to the “animal — plant” system.

Mutualism (+, +)

Mutualism is an interaction in which both partners benefit. In the “animal — plant” system, the classic example is pollination. The plant provides the pollinator with food (nectar, pollen) and/or other resources, while the animal, in turn, ensures the transfer of pollen necessary for plant reproduction (Garibaldi et al., 2013; IPBES, 2016). Another example is myrmecochory (seed dispersal by ants), in which the plant provides ants with nutritious seed appendages (elaiosomes), and the ants carry the seeds away, often placing them in places favorable for germination (Lengyel et al., 2010).

Mutualism can be obligate, when neither partner can exist without the other (for example, some fig species and the agaonid wasps that pollinate them), or facultative, when the partners can survive separately but are better off together (Gullan & Cranston, 2014). In agrocenoses, we most often deal with facultative mutualisms, but their importance is not diminished by this.

Antagonism / Exploitation (+, −)

This is an interaction in which one partner (the animal) benefits at the expense of the other (the plant). In the “animal — plant” system, this type of interaction includes several forms:

1. Phytophagy (or herbivory): The animal consumes living plant tissues. This is the most widespread and well-studied type of interaction, to which we will return in the next section. In terms of sign, this is a classic (+, −) interaction: the animal receives food and energy (+), while the plant loses biomass, which can reduce its survival, growth, and reproduction (−) (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

2. Parasitism: The animal (parasite) lives on or inside the host plant, feeding on its tissues and harming it, but usually not killing it immediately. Examples include some nematodes damaging roots, or gall-forming insects (Gliessman, 2007). Strictly speaking, parasitism is a special case of antagonism, where one organism uses another as a habitat and food source.

3. Allelopathy: Although this interaction is more often considered between plants, animals can also release substances toxic to plants. However, in the context of zoology, it is more correct to speak of direct consumption or damage.

Commensalism (+, 0)

Commensalism is an interaction in which one partner benefits and the other is indifferent (neither harmed nor helped). In the “animal — plant” system, an example may be an animal using a plant as shelter or as a substrate for movement without causing significant damage to the plant. For example, some small arthropods may live in leaf axils or under bark without feeding on the tissues of the host plant (Gullan & Cranston, 2014). Strictly speaking, if the animal does not affect the plant’s fitness, this is commensalism.

Amensalism (−, 0)

Amensalism is an interaction in which one partner experiences a negative influence, while the other experiences neither benefit nor harm. In the context of “animal — plant,” this may manifest, for example, when large ungulates trample plants without specifically feeding on them. The plant is damaged (−), while the animal simply passes by, gaining no benefit and suffering no harm (Weil & Brady, 2017). Another example is the release by animals of substances (for example, urine) that can damage plants, but for the animal itself this effect is neutral.

Competition (−, −)

Competition is an interaction in which both partners experience a negative influence due to struggle for a common limited resource. In the “animal — plant” system, pure competition is rare, since animals and plants usually use different resources. However, one can imagine a situation where an animal and a plant compete for space (for example, a climbing plant and a burrowing animal competing for the same territory) or for water under arid conditions. Much more often, competition arises between phytophagous animals for a plant resource, or between plants for light and nutrients. Nevertheless, as a conceptual category, competition is important for the completeness of classification (Odum, 1971).

Why the Same Group of Animals Cannot Be Unambiguously Classified as “Beneficial” or “Harmful”

The main practical conclusion from this classification is that the sign of an interaction is not a fixed property of a species. It depends on context: on the developmental stage of the organism, on the physiological state of the plant, on environmental conditions, and on the presence of other organisms. The same animal species in different situations can act as a mutualist, antagonist, commensal, or amensal.

Let us consider several examples that may seem contradictory from the standpoint of everyday consciousness but are absolutely logical from an ecological point of view.

Bees: Pollinators and “Destroyers”

Honey bees and wild bees are classic mutualists, pollinating a huge number of cultivated plants. This is their main and most valued role by agronomists (IPBES, 2016). However, in some situations bees can cause direct damage. For example, when collecting pollen they can damage flower anthers, and in search of nectar they can puncture the corolla from the side without pollinating (“nectar theft”). For some crops, for example grapes, bees can become “thieves,” eating berries. Thus, the same animal can be both beneficial (as a pollinator) and harmful (as a consumer of the harvest) (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Ants: Predators and “Herdsmen”

Ants are an extremely diverse group. Many species are active predators, destroying insect pests, which makes them useful for the agrocenosis (Pedigo, 2002). However, the same ants can enter into mutualistic relationships with aphids, scale insects, and mealybugs — pests that suck sap from plants. Ants protect these “their own” phytophages from predators and parasitoids and transfer them to new plants, receiving sweet secretions (honeydew) in return. In this case, ants act to the detriment of the plant, promoting the reproduction of pests (Gullan & Cranston, 2014). Moreover, some leaf-cutter ants (Atta spp.) are serious phytophages, cutting leaves to grow fungi. Thus, ants can simultaneously be predators, mutualists of aphids, and phytophages — and their “usefulness” or “harmfulness” is determined by the specific species and situation.

Birds: Entomophages and Consumers of the Harvest

Many birds bring enormous benefits by eating insect pests. For example, tits, starlings, and woodpeckers can significantly reduce the abundance of caterpillars, beetles, and other phytophages (Pedigo, 2002). This is their role as entomophages (+, − in relation to the pest). However, the same birds can peck ripening fruits, berries, and seeds, causing direct damage to the harvest. Vine growers, gardeners, and farmers are well aware of problems associated with birds and use various methods of scaring them away (Godó et al., 2022). Thus, the same group of animals can act as a “helper” (regulating pest abundance) and as a “pest” (consuming the harvest). Their overall influence on the agrocenosis depends on the balance of these two roles, which, in turn, is determined by abundance, species composition, and availability of alternative foods.

Why Understanding Context Is More Important Than Labels

The examples given show that dividing animals into “beneficial” and “harmful” is a simplification that can lead to incorrect management decisions. For example, destroying all birds in a field can lead to an outbreak of insect pests that were previously controlled by these birds. Or, conversely, preserving ant nests can promote aphid reproduction if ants actively “herd” them.

Modern agroecology and integrated pest management (IPM) proceed from the premise that what must be managed is not individual species but the entire system of interactions. The key concepts here are:

  • Economic threshold: The level of phytophage abundance at which economic damage from its activity exceeds the cost of protective measures. Below this threshold, the phytophage may be present in the agrocenosis without causing significant harm, and may even bring benefit by supporting populations of natural enemies (Pedigo, 2002).
  • Functional group: A group of organisms performing a similar ecological function in a community. For example, all insect pollinators, regardless of their systematic position, form the functional group of pollinators. Management should be aimed at maintaining functional diversity, not individual species (Gliessman, 2007).
  • Ecosystem services: The benefits that people receive from ecosystems. Pollination, biological pest control, decomposition of organic matter, and soil formation are ecosystem services provided by animals. Their conservation and enhancement is a most important task of sustainable agriculture (IPBES, 2016).

Thus, the classification of interactions by sign is not merely an academic exercise. It is a tool that helps the agronomist see the full complexity of the agrocenosis and understand that managing it requires not fighting individual “enemies” and not encouraging individual “friends,” but fine-tuning the entire network of ecological interactions.

In the following sections, we will examine in detail each of the main types of interactions, beginning with the most well-known and frequently discussed — phytophagy.

AliExpress WW

3. Phytophagy: Consumption of Plant Biomass

Moving on to a detailed examination of individual types of interactions, it is logical to begin with phytophagy — the consumption of plant biomass by animals. This interaction is perhaps the most studied and the most significant from a practical point of view, since it is phytophages that historically have been regarded as the main “enemies” of the harvest. However, as we will see, even this seemingly unambiguously antagonistic interaction has its nuances and is not reducible to the simple formula “the animal harms the plant.”

Definition and Place of Phytophagy in the System of Interactions

Phytophagy (from Greek φυτόν — plant and φαγεῖν — to eat) is a type of interaction in which an animal consumes living plant tissues. In the classification by sign, this interaction belongs to the category (+, −) : the animal receives food and energy (+), while the plant loses biomass, which can reduce its survival, growth, and reproduction (−) (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

It is important to understand that phytophagy is not a homogeneous phenomenon. It includes a wide range of mechanisms and strategies that can be classified on various grounds. For agronomic purposes, the most convenient classification is by mode of feeding and nature of damage, since both the nature of the damage and the methods of managing phytophages depend on this.

Types of Phytophagy by Mode of Feeding

The mode of feeding of a phytophage is determined primarily by the structure of its mouthparts and digestive system. This is an evolutionary adaptation to a certain type of plant food and a certain way of extracting it. Four main types of phytophagy are distinguished, which clearly differ in their mechanism of impact on the plant.

1. Chewing Phytophagy

This is the most “straightforward” type of consumption of plant biomass, in which the animal bites off, gnaws, or scrapes pieces of plant tissues. The mouthparts of such phytophages are adapted for mechanical grinding of food — powerful mandibles (jaws) in insects, incisors in rodents, beaks in birds.

Classic examples of chewing phytophages in agrocenoses:

  • Larvae of Lepidoptera (caterpillars): They eat leaves, leaving characteristic holes or eating them from the edges. Caterpillars of cutworms, whites, and tortrix moths are among the most serious pests of agricultural crops (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Leaf beetles (Chrysomelidae): Both adults and larvae feed on leaves, often skeletonizing them (eating out soft tissues and leaving veins). The Colorado potato beetle (Leptinotarsa decemlineata) is a notorious example (Pedigo, 2002).
  • Locusts (Acrididae): During mass reproduction they are capable of completely destroying vegetation cover over vast areas (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Rodents (Rodentia): Mice, rats, and voles consume seeds, fruits, and also green parts of plants. Their role as phytophages in agrocenoses is enormous, especially in warehouses and storage facilities (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Ungulates (Artiodactyla): Cattle, sheep, goats, and also wild ungulates (deer, wild boars) are large chewing phytophages consuming significant volumes of plant biomass on pastures and near fields (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Direct damage from chewing phytophagy consists of:

  • Loss of photosynthetic surface: Removal of leaves directly reduces the plant’s ability to produce organic matter.
  • Loss of storage organs: Eating root crops, tubers, bulbs destroys the already formed harvest.
  • Damage to growing points: Eating apical buds or cambium can completely stop plant growth.
  • Loss of seeds and fruits: Direct reduction of yield.

2. Sucking Phytophagy

This type of feeding is characteristic of animals that do not gnaw tissues but pierce cell walls and suck out the contents of cells or conducting vessels. Their mouthparts are a piercing proboscis (stylet), which is inserted into plant tissues.

Main groups of sucking phytophages:

  • Aphids (Aphididae), mealybugs and scale insects (Coccoidea), whiteflies (Aleyrodidae), psyllids (Psylloidea): These insects from the order Hemiptera feed on the contents of phloem — the conducting tissue through which photosynthesis products are transported. They literally “connect” to the plant’s nutrient distribution system (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Leafhoppers (Cicadellidae) and spittlebugs (Cercopidae): They feed on the contents of xylem — the conducting tissue through which water with dissolved mineral substances moves (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • True bugs (Heteroptera): Many species feed on the contents of mesophyll cells, piercing the epidermis. In doing so, they often inject digestive enzymes, causing local tissue necrosis (Pedigo, 2002).
  • Thrips (Thysanoptera): Small insects that scrape the epidermis and suck out cell contents, leaving characteristic silvery “streaks” on leaves and fruits (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Features of damage from sucking phytophages:

  • Direct loss of nutrients: The plant loses photosynthesis products (when feeding on phloem) or water and mineral substances (when feeding on xylem).
  • Injection of toxic salivary secretions: Many sucking insects release substances into the plant that disrupt its physiological processes. For example, aphid saliva contains enzymes that alter plant metabolism, which can cause leaf deformation, shoot curling, and gall formation (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Transmission of phytopathogens: This is perhaps the most dangerous consequence of sucking phytophagy. Aphids, leafhoppers, whiteflies, and thrips are the main vectors (transmitters) of viral, mycoplasma, and bacterial plant diseases. By piercing a cell, an insect can introduce into it a pathogen obtained from a previous plant (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017). We will discuss this in more detail in the section devoted to vector interactions.
  • Loss of turgor and wilting: Massive sucking of sap from conducting tissues can lead to loss of turgor pressure and wilting of the plant, even if the leaves have not lost a significant area.

3. Mining Phytophagy

This type of feeding is characteristic of insect larvae that live and feed inside plant tissues, making passages (mines) between the epidermis and underlying layers. They eat out soft tissues (parenchyma), leaving the upper and lower epidermis intact, which often looks like a translucent “blister” on the leaf.

Main groups of miners:

  • Leaf-mining flies (Agromyzidae): Larvae of many species mine leaves, stems, and even fruits. For example, the larva of Liriomyza spp. leaves characteristic winding passages on the leaves of tomatoes, cucumbers, and other crops (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Mining moths (Gracillariidae, Nepticulidae, etc.): Larvae of moths mine leaves, forming blotch or linear mines. The apple leaf miner (Phyllonorycter spp.) is a serious pest of orchards (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Sawflies (Tenthredinidae): Some species mine leaves, for example, the birch leaf-mining sawfly (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Leaf beetles: Some species at the larval stage mine leaves (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Damage from mining phytophagy:

  • Reduced photosynthesis: Although the epidermis remains, the destruction of mesophyll inside the mine means that a significant part of the photosynthetic tissue is destroyed. Damaged areas often become necrotic.
  • Reduced market quality: Mines on the leaves of ornamental plants, lettuce, spinach, and other leafy vegetables sharply reduce their market value.
  • Weakening of the plant: Mass development of miners can lead to premature leaf fall and general weakening of the plant.

4. Gall-forming Phytophagy

This type of phytophagy represents the most complex and “sophisticated” interaction between animal and plant. Gall formers do not simply consume plant tissues — they induce the plant to form abnormal growths (galls), which become both a home and a food source for them. A gall is the result of hypertrophy (increase in cell size) and/or hyperplasia (increase in cell number) of plant tissues caused by stimuli from the insect (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Main groups of gall formers:

  • Gall wasps (Cynipidae): They form complex, often species-specific galls on oaks, roses, and other plants. Galls of gall wasps can be so specialized that the insect species can be identified by their shape (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Gall midges (Cecidomyiidae): A family of Diptera, many species of which form galls on leaves, stems, flowers, and roots. For example, the Hessian fly (Mayetiola destructor) forms galls on wheat stems, which leads to lodging of plants (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Aphids, mealybugs, psyllids: Many species from the order Hemiptera are also gall formers. Phylloxera (Daktulosphaira vitifoliae) is a classic example, forming galls on leaves and roots of grapes (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Sawflies (Tenthredinidae): Some species form galls on willows, poplars, and other trees (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Mites (Eriophyidae): Microscopic mites that can also cause gall formation (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Features of gall formation:

  • Reprogramming of plant cells: The insect releases chemical substances (probably together with saliva) that “force” plant cells to divide and grow in a certain way, forming a structure ideally suited for the life and feeding of the larva. The gall becomes for the insect simultaneously a shelter, protection from predators and parasitoids, and a source of highly nutritious tissue (nutritive layer), which constantly regenerates (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Parasitism turning into mutualism? Strictly speaking, gall formation is an antagonistic interaction, since the plant spends resources on forming the gall and loses them to the insect. However, this is not “simple” eating: the insect manipulates the plant’s physiology in its own interests. In some cases, galls may not cause significant damage to the plant if there are few of them.
  • Economic damage: Galls on fruits, stems, or roots can sharply reduce yield and its quality. Grape phylloxera, for example, practically destroyed viticulture in Europe in the 19th century until resistant rootstocks were found (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Direct and Indirect Damage from Phytophagy

The types of phytophagy considered above make it possible to understand that damage to plants can be direct and indirect.

Direct damage is the immediate reduction in the quantity or quality of the harvest as a result of consumption or damage to plant tissues:

  • Reduced photosynthetic activity: Removal of leaf surface (chewing phytophages) or destruction of mesophyll (miners) reduces the plant’s ability to produce organic matter.
  • Loss of harvest: Direct consumption of fruits, seeds, root crops, tubers, and other economically valuable organs.
  • Reduced market quality: Damage to fruits, leaves, and stems makes products unsuitable for sale or processing.
  • Lodging and deformation: Damage to stems and growing points can lead to lodging of plants, curvature of shoots, changes in architecture, which complicates harvesting and reduces yield.

Indirect damage is damage that is not a direct consequence of tissue consumption but arises as a result of secondary effects:

  • Transmission of phytopathogens: As already mentioned, sucking phytophages are the main vectors of viruses, mycoplasmas, and bacteria. In this case, damage from feeding itself may be negligible, but transmission of the disease can destroy the harvest (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017).
  • Weakening of plants: Even minor damage can “open the gates” for secondary infections (fungal, bacterial) and make the plant more vulnerable to abiotic stresses (drought, frost).
  • Changes in plant physiology: Salivary secretions of sucking insects can disrupt hormonal balance, causing, for example, premature aging of leaves or changes in the direction of nutrient transport.
  • Storage losses: Some phytophages (for example, rodents, some insects) continue to feed on the harvested crop in storage, causing significant economic damage after harvest.

Phytophagy as the Most Studied but Not the Only Interaction

Historically, phytophagy has attracted the greatest attention of researchers and practitioners, since it was associated with “pests” — organisms directly reducing yield. This led to the creation of an extensive discipline — agricultural entomology — and the accumulation of an enormous amount of data on the biology, ecology, and control methods of phytophages (Pedigo, 2002).

However, reducing the entire diversity of animal–plant interactions to phytophagy would be a mistake. As we will see in the following sections, animals perform many other, no less important functions in the agrocenosis: pollination, seed dispersal, regulation of phytophage abundance, decomposition of organic matter, and soil formation. These functions often remain “behind the scenes” in the traditional agronomic approach oriented toward pest control. Understanding the entire network of interactions, and not only its antagonistic part, is a necessary condition for the transition to sustainable agriculture.

Brief Reminder About Specific Groups of Phytophages

For completeness of the picture, let us list the main taxonomic groups of animals whose representatives are phytophages in agrocenoses. Their systematics and biology are considered in more detail in the lecture “Systematics and Taxonomy of Organisms in the Agrosphere”.

  • Insects (Insecta): The most numerous and diverse group of phytophages. Key orders: Coleoptera (beetles), Lepidoptera (butterflies), Hemiptera (bugs, aphids, leafhoppers), Diptera (flies), Hymenoptera (sawflies), Orthoptera (locusts), Thysanoptera (thrips).
  • Mites (Acari): Spider mites (Tetranychidae), gall mites (Eriophyidae), flat mites (Tenuipalpidae) — microscopic phytophages sucking out cell contents.
  • Nematodes (Nematoda): Plant-feeding nematodes (Tylenchida and others) damage roots, stems, leaves, and seeds, often also being vectors of viruses.
  • Mollusks (Mollusca): Slugs and snails (Gastropoda) consume leaves, stems, and fruits, especially under moist conditions.
  • Rodents (Rodentia): Mice, rats, and voles — consume seeds, fruits, and green parts of plants, causing damage both in the field and in storage.
  • Ungulates (Artiodactyla): Livestock and wild ungulates — large phytophages affecting pastures and crops.
  • Birds (Aves): Some species (geese, ducks, pigeons, sparrows) consume seeds, fruits, and green parts of plants.

This list is far from complete, but it gives an idea of the taxonomic diversity of phytophages. In the following sections, we will consider other types of interactions that, although not associated with direct consumption of plant biomass, play an equally important role in the functioning of the agrocenosis.

4. Pollination: A Mutualistic Interaction

After considering phytophagy — an antagonistic interaction — it is logical to move on to the opposite type of interaction by sign, namely mutualism. Pollination is perhaps the most vivid and practically most significant example of mutualism in agrocenoses. This is an interaction in which both partners — the plant and the animal — receive mutual benefit, and without which the existence of the overwhelming majority of cultivated plants is impossible.

Pollination as a Key Ecosystem Service

Pollination is the transfer of pollen grains from the anthers (male organs of the flower) to the stigma of the pistil (female organ), which is necessary for fertilization and subsequent formation of seeds and fruits. Although some plants are capable of self-pollination or are pollinated by wind, the overwhelming majority of flowering plants depend on animal pollinators (entomophily, ornithophily, etc.).

From the point of view of classifying interactions by sign, pollination is a classic mutualism (+, +) :

  • The plant benefits (+): Pollen transfer is ensured, necessary for reproduction and yield formation.
  • The animal benefits (+): It receives food (nectar, pollen) and/or other resources necessary for survival and reproduction.

Pollination is a key ecosystem service — that is, a benefit that people receive from the functioning of ecosystems. The global importance of this service is difficult to overestimate. According to estimates, about 75% of all agricultural crops depend to one degree or another on pollinators, and 35% of world food production is directly or indirectly related to animal pollination (IPBES, 2016). The annual market value of products directly dependent on pollination is estimated at 235–577 billion US dollars (IPBES, 2016).

Moreover, pollination is necessary not only for the production of fruits, vegetables, and seeds, but also for maintaining the nutritional value of products. Many pollinated crops are the most important sources of vitamins (especially vitamin A and C), minerals, and other micronutrients in the human diet (IPBES, 2016). Without pollinators, the production of these crops would sharply decline, which would lead to serious consequences for food security and public health.

Finally, pollination plays a critical role in maintaining wild plant communities. About 87.5% of wild flowering plants depend on animal pollinators for reproduction (IPBES, 2016). These wild plants, in turn, form habitats and food resources for many other organisms, supporting the functioning of ecosystems as a whole. Thus, pollination is not only an agronomic but also a general ecological service.

Diversity of Pollinators

Although insects are the most well-known and numerous pollinators, representatives of very different taxonomic groups act in this capacity. Pollinator diversity is not merely an academic interest; it is the key to the stability and reliability of pollination under changing environmental conditions.

1. Insects (Insecta)

Insects are the most numerous and diverse group of pollinators. According to estimates, more than 20,000 species of bees, as well as many species of flies, butterflies, moths, beetles, wasps, and thrips, participate in pollination (IPBES, 2016). In agrocenoses, the following groups are most important:

1) Bees (Apoidea): This is the most important group of pollinators, both in natural and agricultural ecosystems. Bees collect nectar and pollen to feed their larvae and adults, and in doing so effectively transfer pollen between flowers. Among bees, the following are distinguished:

  • Honey bee (Apis mellifera): A domesticated species whose colonies can be transported to fields during flowering. It is the most widely used managed pollinator in the world (IPBES, 2016).
  • Bumblebees (Bombus spp.): Large, hairy bees capable of “buzz” pollination, necessary for some crops such as tomatoes and eggplants. Bumblebees are also more active at low temperatures and in cloudy weather than honey bees (Goulson, 2015).
  • Solitary bees: Numerous species that do not form colonies. They are often more effective as pollinators of specific plants than honey bees, due to their specialization and behavior (Garibaldi et al., 2013).
  • Stingless bees (Meliponini): Important pollinators in tropical regions, where they are native species (IPBES, 2016).

2) Flies (Diptera): Diptera, especially hoverflies (Syrphidae), are important pollinators of many crops. Hoverflies often feed on pollen and nectar, and their larvae can be predators of aphids. Other flies, for example tachinids and robber flies, also visit flowers (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

3) Butterflies and moths (Lepidoptera): Adults feed on nectar using a long proboscis. Butterflies are active during the day, and moths at dusk and at night. They pollinate many plant species, including some cultivated ones (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

4) Beetles (Coleoptera): Beetles were among the first pollinators in evolutionary history. Many beetle species feed on pollen, nectar, or flower tissues. They are especially important for pollinating some primitive flowering plants (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

5) Thrips (Thysanoptera): Small insects that can be both pests and pollinators. Some species actively feed on pollen and participate in pollination (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

6) Wasps (Hymenoptera, other than bees): Some wasps, for example scoliid wasps and tiphiid wasps, visit flowers and can participate in pollination. However, their role as pollinators is less significant than that of bees (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

2. Birds (Aves)

Bird pollinators (ornithophily) are especially characteristic of tropical and subtropical regions. The most well-known groups are hummingbirds (Trochilidae) in America, sunbirds (Nectariniidae) in Africa and Asia, and honeyeaters (Meliphagidae) in Australia. Bird pollinators usually feed on nectar, which they obtain with a long beak and tongue. In agrocenoses of tropical countries, birds can pollinate crops such as banana, papaya, and some legumes (IPBES, 2016).

3. Mammals (Mammalia)

Bats (Chiroptera) are the most important group of mammal pollinators. Bats pollinate plants that flower at night, for example agave (from which tequila is produced), durian, some cacti, and bananas. Other mammals, such as some primates, rodents, and marsupials, can also participate in pollination, but their role is less significant (IPBES, 2016).

Specialization and Generalization of Pollinators

Relationships between plants and pollinators can be specialized (narrow) or generalized (broad). These two types of strategies have different ecological and evolutionary consequences.

Specialization (oligolecty and monolecty)

Some plants attract only one species or a few closely related species of pollinators. This may be the result of coevolution — mutual adaptation of plant and pollinator to each other. Examples of specialization:

  • Orchids and euglossine bees: Some orchids attract only males of certain bee species by imitating the scent of females. Bees collect aromatic substances, and the orchid receives pollination (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Figs and agaonid wasps: Each fig species is pollinated by one or several species of agaonid wasps, which, in turn, reproduce only in fig flowers. This is obligate mutualism (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Yucca and yucca moths: Yucca moths pollinate yucca and lay eggs in its flowers, and the larvae feed on part of the seeds. This is also obligate mutualism (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Specialization can be beneficial for the plant, as it ensures pollination accuracy — the pollinator reliably transfers pollen to a flower of the same species. However, specialization makes the plant vulnerable to the disappearance of its pollinator. If a specialized pollinator goes extinct, the plant may not survive.

Generalization (polylecty)

Most plants are pollinated by a wide range of animal pollinators. For example, many crops, such as sunflower, buckwheat, and apple, are visited by dozens of species of bees, flies, butterflies, and beetles. Generalization ensures reliability of pollination: if one pollinator is absent, its function can be performed by others. This is especially important in agrocenoses, where pollinator diversity may be reduced due to intensive farming.

However, generalization also has its drawbacks. Different pollinators may be unequally effective. For example, honey bees may be less effective for pollinating some crops than wild bees, since they may collect nectar without touching the stigma, or prefer other plants (Garibaldi et al., 2013). In addition, generalists may transfer pollen from other, undesirable plant species, which reduces pollination efficiency.

Why Crop Production Depends on Pollinators

The dependence of crop production on pollinators is enormous and multifaceted. It manifests at several levels:

1. Yield formation

For many crops, pollination is an obligatory condition for the formation of fruits and seeds. Without pollination, flowers simply fall off without forming an ovary. This applies to crops such as:

  • Fruit crops: apple, pear, cherry, plum, apricot, peach, almond.
  • Berry crops: strawberry, raspberry, blackberry, blueberry, cranberry.
  • Cucurbit crops: cucumbers, watermelons, melons, pumpkins.
  • Vegetable crops: tomatoes (especially in greenhouses), eggplants, peppers, legumes.
  • Oilseed crops: sunflower, rapeseed, castor bean.
  • Fiber crops: cotton.
  • Forage crops: alfalfa, clover.

2. Yield quality

Even for crops that can partially be pollinated by wind or self-pollinated, animal pollinators can significantly improve product quality:

  • Fruit size: Pollination increases the number of seeds, which in turn stimulates fruit growth. For example, apples and pears with more seeds are larger and have a more regular shape.
  • Fruit shape: Uneven pollination can lead to asymmetry of fruits (for example, in apples and cucumbers). Good pollination ensures uniform development of all parts of the fruit.
  • Taste and nutritional value: Pollination affects the content of sugars, vitamins, and other useful substances in fruits. For example, strawberries pollinated by bees contain more sugars and vitamin C (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Storage life: Fruits formed as a result of full pollination store better and are less susceptible to rotting.

3. Production stability

Pollinator diversity ensures stability of production even under unfavorable conditions. If one pollinator species reduces its activity due to weather, diseases, or other factors, other species can compensate for its absence. Studies show that crop yields are higher and more stable in agrocenoses where a diverse community of wild pollinators is present, even with managed honey bees (Garibaldi et al., 2013).

Moreover, wild pollinators often turn out to be more effective than honey bees. The study by Garibaldi et al. (2013), covering 41 crop cultivation systems worldwide, showed that:

  • Visits to flowers by wild insects increased fruit set in all studied systems.
  • Visits by honey bees increased fruit set only in 14% of systems.
  • The increase in fruit set from visits by wild insects was twice as strong as from an equivalent increase in visits by honey bees.
  • Visits by wild insects and honey bees complemented each other rather than replaced each other. High abundance of honey bees did not compensate for the absence of wild pollinators.

This study convincingly demonstrates that conservation of wild pollinator diversity is critically important for sustainable crop production. Relying exclusively on one species (the honey bee) makes production vulnerable and does not allow maximum yield to be achieved.

Brief Reminder About Specific Groups of Pollinators

To reinforce the material, let us list the main taxonomic groups of animals participating in pollination in agrocenoses:

1) Insects (Insecta):

  • Hymenoptera: bees (honey, bumblebees, solitary, stingless), wasps.
  • Diptera: hoverflies, tachinids, robber flies, some flies.
  • Lepidoptera: butterflies, moths.
  • Coleoptera: beetles (some species).
  • Thysanoptera: thrips (some species).

2) Birds (Aves): hummingbirds, sunbirds, honeyeaters (in the tropics).

3) Mammals (Mammalia): bats, some primates, rodents (in the tropics).

Understanding the diversity of pollinators, their ecological requirements, and their relationships with plants is the basis for developing strategies for managing agrocenoses aimed at maintaining and enhancing this key ecosystem service. In the following sections, we will consider other types of mutualistic interactions, as well as interactions that do not fit into the simple dichotomy of “benefit–harm.”

5. Dispersal of Seeds and Fruits

After considering pollination — a mutualistic interaction associated with plant reproduction — it is logical to move on to another type of mutualism that also plays a key role in plant life cycles but often remains in the shadows. This refers to zoochory — the dispersal of seeds and fruits by animals.

Definition and Place of Zoochory in the System of Interactions

Zoochory (from Greek ζῷον — animal and χωρέω — I spread) is a type of interaction in which animals act as agents of dispersal (dispersion) of seeds and fruits of plants. From the point of view of classification by sign, zoochory in most cases represents mutualism (+, +) or, in some cases, commensalism (+, 0) :

  • The plant benefits (+): Seeds are transferred to a new place, which reduces competition with the parent plant, allows colonization of new habitats, and expands the range.
  • The animal benefits (+): It receives food (fruits, seeds, elaiosomes) or other resources (for example, material for a nest).
  • In some cases (0): The animal may not derive direct benefit but also does not harm the plant, accidentally transferring seeds on its surface.

It is important to emphasize that zoochory is not simply “eating fruits.” It is a complex evolutionarily developed mechanism in which the plant “uses” the animal to solve one of its key life tasks — dispersing its offspring. Unlike pollination, which ensures sexual reproduction (formation of seeds), zoochory ensures the dispersal of already formed seeds, which is no less important for the survival of the species.

Types of Zoochory

Zoochory includes several fundamentally different mechanisms that differ in the method of seed transfer, degree of specialization, and ecological consequences. Three main types are distinguished: endozoochory, epizoochory, and synzoochory. Adjacent to them is myrmecochory — a special case of synzoochory associated with ants.

1. Endozoochory

Endozoochory is the dispersal of seeds that pass through the digestive tract of an animal and are excreted undamaged (or with a partially damaged coat) together with feces. This is perhaps the most well-known and widespread type of zoochory, which we often observe when birds or mammals eat succulent fruits.

Mechanism:

1. The animal eats the fruit (berry, drupe, etc.) for its nutritious pulp.

2. Seeds, protected by a hard coat, pass through the digestive system without being digested.

3. Seeds are excreted with feces in a new place, often at a considerable distance from the parent plant.

4. The animal thus not only transfers the seeds but also “fertilizes” them, creating favorable conditions for germination.

Examples in agrocenoses and natural ecosystems:

  • Birds: Thrushes, waxwings, jays, magpies, and many other birds eat the berries of rowan, bird cherry, hawthorn, honeysuckle, as well as the fruits of cultivated plants (cherry, sweet cherry, grapes). The seeds of these plants often retain viability after passing through the bird’s intestine (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Mammals: Foxes, badgers, bears, martens, as well as rodents (mice, voles) and ungulates (deer, wild boars) eat fruits and berries, dispersing seeds over long distances. For example, wild boars actively disperse the seeds of wild apples and pears (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Reptiles: Some turtles and lizards also participate in endozoochory, especially in tropical regions.

Significance for plants:

  • Dispersal distance: Animals can transfer seeds over distances from several tens of meters to several kilometers, significantly exceeding the capabilities of wind or gravity.
  • Directed transfer: Animals often transfer seeds to certain places (for example, under shelters, into burrows, to forest edges), which may be favorable for germination.
  • Scarification: Passage through the digestive tract can partially destroy the hard seed coat (scarification), which stimulates germination.

Limitations:

  • Seed damage: Not all seeds survive passage through the digestive tract. Large seeds with a hard coat have a better chance than small and soft ones.
  • Dependence on specific species: A plant may depend on certain species of endozoochorous animals, and the disappearance of these animals can lead to reduced seed dispersal.

2. Epizoochory

Epizoochory is the dispersal of seeds that attach to the external covers of animals (fur, feathers, paws, beak) and are carried on them. This type of zoochory is not associated with eating fruits; instead, plants have developed special adaptations for “sticking” to animals.

Mechanism:

1. Seeds or fruits have special structures for attachment: hooks, spines, sticky hairs, adhesive substances.

2. These structures catch on the fur, feathers, or skin of an animal when it passes by the plant.

3. The animal carries the seeds some distance until they fall off or are removed during grooming.

4. Seeds land in a new place, often in places visited by animals (trails, burrows, pastures).

Examples:

  • Plants with clinging fruits: Burdock (Arctium spp.), beggarticks (Bidens spp.), avens (Geum spp.), bedstraw (Galium spp.) — classic examples of plants whose fruits cling to animal fur and human clothing.
  • Carrier animals: Mammals (especially with thick fur — sheep, dogs, foxes, hares), birds (especially with dense plumage), and also large ungulates (cows, deer, horses).
  • In agrocenoses: Epizoochory can promote the spread of weed plants. For example, seeds of burdock or beggarticks can attach to the fur of livestock and be transferred to new fields (Godó et al., 2022).

Significance for plants:

  • Dispersal distance: Depends on the mobility of the animal. Large ungulates and birds can transfer seeds over significant distances (from several hundred meters to several kilometers).
  • Specialization: Some plants have highly specialized structures for attachment to certain types of animals (for example, to fur of a certain structure).

Limitations:

  • Dependence on the animal: Epizoochory is possible only in the presence of suitable carrier animals.
  • Risk of seed loss: Seeds may fall off in an unfavorable place or be eaten along with fur during grooming.

3. Synzoochory

Synzoochory is the dispersal of seeds associated with food storage by animals. Animals collect seeds and fruits, carry them to certain places (burrows, storehouses, hollows), and store them for a period of food shortage. Some of these stores are subsequently not used and give rise to new plants.

Mechanism:

1. The animal collects seeds or fruits (often preferring certain species).

2. It carries them to a storage place (burrow, hollow, litter, crack in bark).

3. Seeds are stored for some time.

4. Part of the stores remains unused (due to the death of the animal, excess food, forgetfulness) and germinates in a new place.

Examples:

  • Squirrels and chipmunks: Store nuts, acorns, conifer seeds. They create “caches” — small pits in which they hide several seeds. Some of these caches remain unclaimed, and the seeds germinate (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Jays: Store acorns, creating oak “plantations.” It is known that jays played a key role in the post-glacial spread of oak in Europe (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Mouse-like rodents: Store seeds of grasses, cereals, and trees. Their caches can contain thousands of seeds. Part of the stores germinates.
  • Nutcrackers: Store seeds of Siberian pine, creating “cedar gardens” in the taiga.

Significance for plants:

  • Purposeful transfer: Animals often transfer seeds to certain types of habitats (for example, under tree crowns, into soil), which may be favorable for germination.
  • Protection from predators: Seeds hidden in caches are protected from many consumers.
  • Dispersal distance: Can be significant, especially in birds and large rodents.

Limitations:

  • Dependence on animal behavior: Synzoochory is possible only in the presence of animals with appropriate storing behavior.
  • Risk of being eaten: Most stores are nevertheless eaten, and only a small proportion of seeds give rise to new plants.

4. Myrmecochory

Myrmecochory is a specialized type of synzoochory in which seeds are dispersed by ants. This is perhaps the most studied and ecologically significant type of zoochory for herbaceous plants.

Mechanism:

1. Seeds of myrmecochorous plants have a special nutritious appendage — an elaiosome (from Greek ἔλαιον — oil and σῶμα — body), rich in lipids and proteins.

2. Ants are attracted by the smell of the elaiosome, collect the seeds, and carry them to their nests.

3. In the nest, the elaiosome is eaten (often by larvae), while the seed itself remains undamaged.

4. Seeds are thrown out into “waste” or onto “garbage piles” inside or near the nest, where they germinate.

Examples:

  • Violets (Viola spp.): Many violet species have seeds with elaiosomes and are dispersed by ants (Lengyel et al., 2010).
  • Corydalis (Corydalis spp.): Also myrmecochorous; their seeds are actively collected by ants.
  • Many species from the families: Achariaceae, Aizoaceae, Amaranthaceae, Amaryllidaceae, Apiaceae, Asteraceae, Boraginaceae, Brassicaceae, Caryophyllaceae, Euphorbiaceae, Fabaceae, Lamiaceae, Papaveraceae, Poaceae, Ranunculaceae, Scrophulariaceae, and many others (Lengyel et al., 2010).

Scale of the phenomenon:

  • Myrmecochory is distributed worldwide but is especially characteristic of three regions: (1) Australia, (2) South Africa (Cape flora), (3) temperate forests of the Northern Hemisphere (Lengyel et al., 2010).
  • According to estimates, myrmecochory occurs in more than 11,000 species of angiosperms, which is about 4.5% of all species (Lengyel et al., 2010).
  • Myrmecochory arose independently at least 100 times in the evolutionary history of angiosperms (Lengyel et al., 2010).

Significance for plants:

  • Transfer to safe places: Ant nests are often located in places protected from fires, predators, and competitors.
  • Nutritious environment: Ant “garbage piles” are rich in organic matter and nutrients, which promotes germination and growth of seedlings.
  • Protection from predators: Seeds located in the nest are protected from many seed consumers (birds, rodents).

Limitations:

  • Short distances: Ants transfer seeds over relatively short distances (usually from several centimeters to several meters), although in some cases up to tens of meters.
  • Dependence on the presence of ants: Myrmecochory is possible only in the presence of suitable ant species.

Role of Zoochory in the Dispersal of Cultivated and Wild Plants

Zoochory plays a fundamental role in maintaining and restoring plant communities, both wild and cultivated. Understanding this interaction is necessary for solving a number of practical tasks — from biodiversity conservation to restoration of degraded lands.

1. Dispersal of wild plants

For wild plants, zoochory is the main mechanism for colonizing new habitats and maintaining metapopulation dynamics. Zoochorous animals connect isolated habitat fragments, transferring seeds between them. This is especially important under conditions of landscape fragmentation caused by human activity.

2. Dispersal of cultivated plants

Although cultivated plants are usually sown by humans, zoochory can play an important role in some agrocenoses:

  • Spread of weed plants: Birds and mammals, eating the fruits of weed plants, can promote their spread to new fields. For example, seeds of nightshade, goosefoot, and amaranth are often dispersed by birds (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Spread of cultivated plants into natural ecosystems: Birds and mammals can eat the fruits of cultivated plants (cherry, grapes, apple) and disperse their seeds into surrounding natural communities. This can lead to the “feralization” of cultivated plants and their introduction into natural ecosystems (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Restoration of populations of rare and endangered species: Zoochory can be used to restore populations of rare plants. For example, planting fruit-bearing plants that attract endozoochorous birds can promote natural seed dispersal into suitable habitats.

3. Ecosystem restoration

Understanding zoochory is critically important for ecological restoration — the restoration of degraded ecosystems. Passive restoration often relies on natural seed dispersal by animals. For example:

  • Restoration of tropical forests: Birds and bats that eat the fruits of pioneer trees can promote the introduction of seeds onto abandoned pastures and fields, accelerating the restoration of forest cover.
  • Restoration of steppes and meadows: Myrmecochory and epizoochory can promote the restoration of herbaceous communities. For example, ants can transfer seeds of steppe plants to restored areas.
  • Planning restoration measures: Knowing which animals are key zoochores for target plant species allows purposeful creation of conditions for attracting them (for example, planting lure plants, creating shelters).

Why Zoochory Is Often Underestimated in Agronomy

Despite the fundamental importance of zoochory, traditional agronomy pays much less attention to it than, for example, to pollination or phytophagy. The reasons for this can be understood, but their consequences require revision.

1. Orientation toward monocultures

Traditional agriculture is oriented toward growing monocultures, where humans fully control the process of plant reproduction. Seeds are sown at the right time and in the right place. In such a system, natural zoochory is not only unnecessary but often undesirable (for example, when birds disperse seeds of weed plants).

2. Difficulty of observation and quantification

Zoochory is a process that is difficult to observe and measure. Zoochorous animals are often active at dusk or at night, transfer seeds over long distances, and their contribution to seed dispersal is not always obvious. This complicates both scientific research and practical application of knowledge about zoochory.

3. Underestimation of ecosystem services

For a long time, zoochory was not considered an ecosystem service with economic value. However, in recent decades the situation has been changing. Studies show that zoochory contributes to:

  • Maintenance of biodiversity: Animal seed dispersal supports plant diversity, which in turn supports the diversity of other organisms.
  • Restoration of forests and other ecosystems: Natural restoration of vegetation reduces the costs of reforestation and land restoration.
  • Sustainability of agrocenoses: The presence of diverse zoochores in the agricultural landscape can help maintain useful wild plants (for example, pollinators, entomophages).

4. Connection with other ecosystem services

Zoochory is closely connected with other ecosystem services. For example, animals that disperse seeds are often also pollinators or entomophages. Preserving their habitats (forest belts, hedgerows, forest edges) supports several ecosystem services at once, which makes such measures economically and ecologically effective.

Why Understanding Zoochory Is Important for Ecosystem Restoration

Restoration of degraded ecosystems is one of the key tasks of our time. Zoochory provides a powerful but often underestimated tool for solving this task.

1. Passive restoration

Passive restoration relies on natural processes, including seed dispersal by animals. If seed sources (for example, forest fragments) and zoochorous animals remain in the landscape, natural restoration can occur without expensive plantings. For example:

  • Restoration of tropical forests: Birds and bats that eat the fruits of pioneer trees can promote the introduction of seeds onto abandoned pastures. Studies show that under “perch trees” (artificially created perch trees) more seeds accumulate than in open areas, which accelerates forest restoration (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Restoration of steppes: Myrmecochorous ants can transfer seeds of steppe plants to restored areas. Creating conditions for their activity (for example, preserving undisturbed soil areas) can promote vegetation restoration.

2. Active restoration

Active restoration may include purposeful attraction of zoochorous animals. For example:

  • Creation of bird perches: Installation of artificial perches (poles, dead trees) in restored areas attracts birds, which leave seeds with feces. This is a simple and inexpensive method that can significantly accelerate the restoration of forest cover.
  • Planting lure plants: Planting fruit-bearing plants that attract birds and mammals can promote the introduction of seeds of target species.
  • Preservation and creation of habitats for zoochores: Hedgerows, forest belts, shrub thickets are habitats for birds, mammals, and ants, which can be sources of seeds for restored areas.

3. Monitoring and evaluation

Understanding zoochory allows developing methods for monitoring and evaluating the effectiveness of restoration measures. For example, analysis of the contents of animal feces or the contents of ant nests can show which seeds and in what quantity are transferred to restored areas.

Brief Reminder About Specific Groups of Zoochores

To reinforce the material, let us list the main taxonomic groups of animals participating in zoochory:

1) Birds (Aves): Main endozoochores (thrushes, waxwings, jays, magpies) and epizoochores (birds with clinging feathers).

2) Mammals (Mammalia):

  • Endozoochores: Foxes, badgers, bears, martens, wild boars, deer, rodents (mice, voles).
  • Synzoochores: Squirrels, chipmunks, jays, nutcrackers, mouse-like rodents.
  • Epizoochores: Ungulates (cows, sheep, deer), predators with thick fur.

3) Ants (Formicidae): Myrmecochores — transfer seeds with elaiosomes.

4) Reptiles (Reptilia): Some turtles and lizards (endozoochory in the tropics).

5) Insects (Insecta): Some dung beetles (endozoochory), crickets, grasshoppers (epizoochory).

Zoochory is not simply a “side effect” of animal feeding. It is a complex, evolutionarily developed mechanism that links the animal and plant worlds into a single functional network. Understanding this mechanism is necessary for managing agrocenoses and natural ecosystems, especially in the context of biodiversity conservation and restoration of degraded lands.

In the next section, we will consider another aspect of animal–plant interactions that may seem unexpected: phytophagy as a “service” — the consumption of weeds.

6. Phytophagy as a “Service”: Consumption of Weeds

In previous sections, we considered phytophagy mainly as an antagonistic interaction causing damage to cultivated plants. However, this is only one side of the coin. In a certain context, phytophagy can act as an ecosystem service, helping reduce the abundance of undesirable plants — weeds — and thereby reducing their competition with cultivated species. This aspect of animal–plant interaction often remains in the shadows, but its importance for sustainable agriculture is difficult to overestimate.

Weeds as an Object of Phytophagy

Weeds are plants growing in an agrocenosis but not being the target crop. They compete with cultivated plants for light, water, nutrients, and space, which can lead to significant yield losses. According to estimates, weeds are one of the main causes of reduced crop yields worldwide (Pedigo, 2002). Traditionally, weed control is carried out using mechanical (weeding, cultivation) or chemical (herbicides) methods. However, both approaches have their limitations: mechanical treatment is labor-intensive and can damage the soil, while herbicides pollute the environment and promote the development of resistance in weed plants (Gliessman, 2007).

In this context, phytophages that feed on weed plants can be regarded as natural “helpers” of the farmer, reducing the abundance and competitiveness of weeds without chemicals. This is an example of how an antagonistic interaction (a phytophage eats a plant) can be useful from the human point of view if the object of feeding is an undesirable species.

Herbivorous Fish in Rice Paddies

One of the most striking and well-documented examples of using phytophagy for weed control is integrated rice farming with the cultivation of herbivorous fish. This practice, known as rice–fish farming, has a centuries-long history, especially in Southeast Asian countries (Pillay, 2005).

Mechanism:

1. In rice paddies filled with water, fry of herbivorous fish are released (for example, grass carp, Ctenopharyngodon idella).

2. Fish feed on aquatic plants, including weeds, which compete with rice for nutrients and light.

3. Reduction in weed abundance promotes better growth and development of rice.

4. Fish also eat insect pests and their larvae living in the water, which gives an additional effect.

5. Fish excrement fertilizes the water and soil, increasing its fertility.

6. At the end of the season, the fish are caught and used for food, which gives the farmer an additional source of income and protein (Pillay, 2005).

Ecological and agronomic advantages:

  • Reduced herbicide costs: Fish replace chemical means of weed control.
  • Improved soil fertility: Fish excrement enriches water and soil with nutrients.
  • Additional source of income: Fish cultivation gives additional products.
  • Reduced pest abundance: Fish eat mosquito larvae and other insects, including potential rice pests.
  • System sustainability: Integrated rice–fish farming is more resistant to fluctuations in rice and herbicide prices, as well as to climate change (Pillay, 2005).

Limitations:

  • Water requirements: Fish cultivation requires a certain water level in paddies, which can be a problem in arid regions.
  • Dependence on fish species: Not all fish species are suitable for rice–fish systems; species are needed that do not damage rice and effectively consume weeds.
  • Management complexity: Integrated farming requires more complex management than rice monoculture.
  • Pesticides: The use of some pesticides may be toxic to fish, which requires careful selection of chemicals or their abandonment (Pillay, 2005).

Despite these limitations, rice–fish farming remains an example of the successful use of phytophagy for weed control and increasing the sustainability of the agrocenosis.

Phytophagous Insects in Weed Biocontrol

Another example of using phytophagy as a service is classical biological control of weed plants with the help of phytophagous insects. This method is based on the fact that many weed plants in their natural habitats have specialized phytophagous insects that restrain their abundance. When a plant enters a new environment without its natural enemies, it can become invasive and cause significant damage to agriculture and natural ecosystems. Introduction of these specialized phytophages can help restore control over the invasive species (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Classic examples:

  • Cactus Opuntia and the moth Cactoblastis cactorum: Cacti of the genus Opuntia became a serious weed in Australia in the 19th century, occupying millions of hectares of pastures. In 1925, the moth Cactoblastis cactorum was introduced from South America, whose larvae feed on cactus tissues. Within a few years, the moth practically completely destroyed cactus thickets, restoring pastures (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • St. John’s wort Hypericum perforatum and leaf beetles Chrysolina spp.: St. John’s wort, introduced to North America and Australia, became a serious pasture weed. Introduction of two species of leaf beetles (Chrysolina quadrigemina and C. hyperici) from Europe led to a significant reduction in St. John’s wort abundance and restoration of pastures (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Salvinia Salvinia molesta and the weevil Cyrtobagous salviniae: The aquatic fern salvinia became a serious problem in tropical water bodies worldwide. Introduction of the weevil Cyrtobagous salviniae from Brazil led to successful control of salvinia in Africa, Asia, and Australia. The beetles feed on buds and rhizomes of the plant, which leads to its death (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Advantages of weed biocontrol:

  • Sustainability: After establishment of the phytophage population, control can be maintained for many years without additional costs.
  • Specificity: Properly selected phytophages attack only the target weed without damaging cultivated plants.
  • Environmentally friendly: Biocontrol does not pollute the environment, unlike herbicides.
  • Economic efficiency: Although initial costs for research and introduction may be high, long-term benefits usually outweigh them (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Limitations and risks:

  • Unpredictability: It is not always possible to predict how effective an introduced phytophage will be in a new environment.
  • Risk to non-target species: Some phytophages may feed not only on the target weed but also on closely related cultivated or wild plants. This requires careful testing before introduction.
  • Long-term nature: It may take several years to obtain a result.
  • Irreversibility: Introduced species cannot be “recalled” if they begin to cause undesirable damage (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

An example of risk is the introduction of the moth Cactoblastis cactorum to the Caribbean region, where it began attacking local cactus species, including rare and protected ones. This shows that biocontrol requires careful assessment of potential risks (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Livestock Grazing as a Tool for Vegetation Management

Another example of using phytophagy as a service is managed livestock grazing for controlling undesirable vegetation. While in previous sections we considered ungulates as potential pests damaging cultivated plants, with proper management they can be an effective tool for suppressing weeds and maintaining the desired composition of the plant community.

Mechanism:

1. Livestock (cows, sheep, goats, horses) graze on a certain area at a certain time.

2. Animals eat preferred plant species, reducing their abundance and competitiveness.

3. With proper grazing planning, undesirable species (weeds) can be suppressed and desirable ones (forage grasses, legumes) promoted.

4. Animal excrement returns nutrients to the soil, increasing its fertility.

Examples:

  • Control of shrubs and trees on pastures: Goats and sheep actively eat young shoots of shrubs and trees, preventing their spread on pastures.
  • Control of invasive grasses: Managed grazing can suppress the growth of invasive grasses such as Bromus tectorum (cheatgrass) in North America.
  • Maintenance of steppe and meadow communities: Grazing imitates natural processes that maintain the biodiversity of herbaceous communities. Without grazing, steppes and meadows become overgrown with shrubs and trees, losing their unique species composition (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Advantages:

  • Economy: Grazing can be cheaper than mechanical or chemical weed control.
  • Environmentally friendly: Grazing does not pollute the environment.
  • Multifunctionality: Grazing simultaneously provides livestock products and maintains plant communities.
  • Maintenance of biodiversity: Moderate grazing can help preserve the diversity of herbaceous plants (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Limitations and risks:

  • Overgrazing: Excessive grazing can lead to pasture degradation, soil erosion, and reduced biodiversity.
  • Selectivity: Animals may prefer some plant species over others, which can lead to undesirable changes in the composition of the plant community.
  • Soil compaction: Ungulates can compact the soil, reducing its water permeability and aeration.
  • Management requirements: Effective use of grazing for weed control requires careful planning and monitoring (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Why This Interaction Is Important for Sustainable Agriculture

Using phytophagy for weed control is an important element of sustainable agriculture — an approach that strives to minimize negative environmental impact, preserve natural resources, and ensure long-term productivity of agrocenoses.

1. Reducing dependence on herbicides

Herbicides are one of the main tools for weed control in modern agriculture. However, their use is associated with a number of problems:

  • Environmental pollution: Herbicides can enter groundwater, rivers, and lakes, damaging aquatic ecosystems.
  • Weed resistance: Many weed species have developed resistance to commonly used herbicides, making their use less effective.
  • Impact on non-target organisms: Herbicides can be toxic to beneficial insects, birds, and other animals (Gliessman, 2007).

Using phytophages for weed control makes it possible to reduce dependence on herbicides, decreasing their negative impact on the environment.

2. Increasing biodiversity

Integrated systems such as rice–fish farming or managed grazing create more diverse habitats for wild animals. For example, rice paddies with fish attract aquatic insects, amphibians, and birds. This increases the overall biodiversity of the agricultural landscape and supports ecosystem services such as pollination and biological pest control (Pillay, 2005).

3. Economic efficiency

Although integrated systems may require more complex management, they often turn out to be more economically efficient in the long term. Reduced herbicide costs, additional products (fish, meat, wool), and increased system resilience to unfavorable conditions make such approaches attractive to farmers (Pillay, 2005).

4. Resilience to climate change

Integrated systems based on the use of natural processes are often more resistant to climatic fluctuations. For example, rice–fish systems tolerate droughts and floods better than rice monoculture, thanks to the presence of water and the diversity of organisms capable of adapting to changing conditions (Pillay, 2005).

Brief Reminder About Specific Groups of Phytophages Used for Weed Control

To reinforce the material, let us list the main taxonomic groups of animals that can be used for weed control:

1) Fish (Pisces):

  • Grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella): A herbivorous fish actively eating aquatic plants, including weeds.
  • Silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys spp.): Feeds on phytoplankton, helping improve water quality.
  • Common carp (Cyprinus carpio): Omnivorous, can eat seeds and seedlings of weeds.

2) Insects (Insecta):

  • Leaf beetles (Chrysomelidae): Many species are used for weed biocontrol (for example, Chrysolina spp. against St. John’s wort).
  • Weevils (Curculionidae): Used for control of aquatic and terrestrial weeds (for example, Cyrtobagous salviniae against salvinia).
  • Moths (Lepidoptera): Some species are used for control of cacti and other weeds (for example, Cactoblastis cactorum).
  • Gall midges (Cecidomyiidae): Some species are used for weed control.

3) Mammals (Mammalia):

  • Ungulates (Artiodactyla): Cows, sheep, goats, horses — used for managed grazing.
  • Rodents (Rodentia): In some cases can be used for control of weed seeds, but more often they are themselves pests.

Using phytophagy for weed control is an example of how ecological knowledge can be applied to solve practical agricultural problems. However, like any intervention in an ecosystem, it requires caution, careful planning, and monitoring. In the next section, we will consider mechanical interactions — another type of animal influence on plants that often remains underestimated.

7. Mechanical Interactions: Bioturbation, Trampling, Burrowing

Until now, we have considered animal–plant interactions mainly through the prism of feeding: who eats whom, who pollinates whom, who disperses whom. However, there is another extensive class of interactions that is not associated with direct consumption of plant biomass but has an enormous influence on plants. This refers to mechanical interactions — the physical impact of animals on the habitat of plants and on the plants themselves. These interactions can be both beneficial and harmful, and underestimating them leads to an incomplete understanding of the functioning of the agrocenosis.

Bioturbation: Mixing and Transformation of Soil

Bioturbation (from Greek βίος — life and Latin turbatio — disturbance, agitation) is the process of mixing and transformation of soil and bottom sediments by living organisms. In the context of an agrocenosis, bioturbation is primarily the activity of ecosystem engineers — animals that actively change the physical structure of the soil, creating, modifying, or maintaining habitats for other organisms (Weil & Brady, 2017; Straalen, 2023).

Earthworms: “Plows” of the Soil World

Earthworms are perhaps the most well-known and important bioturbators in temperate latitudes. Their activity includes several key processes:

1. Burrowing (tunneling): Earthworms make passages in the soil that can be horizontal (in endogeic species) or vertical, going to a depth of several meters (in anecic species such as Lumbricus terrestris). These passages increase porosity of the soil, improve aeration and water permeability. In one hectare of soil, earthworms can create a system of passages with a total length of hundreds of kilometers (Weil & Brady, 2017).

2. Ingestion and excretion of soil: Earthworms swallow soil and organic residues, digest them, and excrete coprolites (excrement) — granular aggregates rich in organic matter and nutrients. Per year, earthworms can process from 20 to 1000 tons of soil per hectare, depending on climate and population density (Weil & Brady, 2017). Coprolites have high water resistance and mechanical strength, which contributes to the formation of agronomically valuable soil structure.

3. Transfer of organic matter downward: Anecic worms drag plant residues from the surface into their burrows, where they decompose, enriching deep soil layers with organic carbon and nitrogen. This contributes to carbon sequestration and improved fertility of subsoil horizons (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Ants and Termites: Tropical “Architects”

In tropical and subtropical regions, the role of earthworms as bioturbators often passes to ants and termites. These insects create complex underground and aboveground structures — nests, galleries, mounds — which radically change the physical properties of the soil:

  • Ants: Many ant species build underground nests with numerous chambers and passages. During construction they move enormous volumes of soil, enriching it with organic matter and nutrients. Studies show that soil in ant nests often contains more nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium than surrounding soil and supports a more diverse microbial community (Weil & Brady, 2017). In addition, ant passages improve water permeability and aeration of the soil, which favorably affects plant growth.
  • Termites: Termites are among the most significant bioturbators in tropical savannas and forests. They build huge mounds (termite mounds) that can reach several meters in height. During construction, termites move soil from deep horizons to the surface and vice versa, creating “islands of fertility” with increased content of clay, nutrients, and organic matter. Termites also create a system of underground passages that improve drainage and aeration of the soil (Weil & Brady, 2017). In some regions, termites annually move up to 2.4 million kg of soil per hectare — this is equivalent to a soil layer about 20 cm thick (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Rodents and Other Burrowing Animals

Rodents (mice, voles, ground squirrels, mole rats), as well as moles, shrews, and other burrowing mammals, make a significant contribution to bioturbation, especially in steppes, meadows, and pastures:

  • Burrow digging: When creating burrows, rodents throw significant volumes of soil enriched with nutrients from deep horizons onto the surface. These mounds (molehill-like mounds) create microhabitats with different conditions of moisture, temperature, and fertility, which contributes to increased diversity of plant communities (Godó et al., 2022; Straalen, 2023).
  • Root damage: The burrowing activity of rodents can damage the roots of cultivated plants, which is a negative effect. However, in natural ecosystems this contributes to aeration of the soil and stimulates the growth of new roots.
  • Soil mixing: Rodents mix the soil, transferring organic residues from the surface to depth and mineral particles upward. This accelerates decomposition of organic matter and cycling of nutrients (Straalen, 2023).

Trampling: Soil Compaction and Plant Damage

Trampling is the mechanical impact of animals on soil and plants associated with their movement over the surface. The most significant agents of trampling are large ungulates — both domestic (cows, sheep, goats, horses) and wild (deer, wild boars, bison).

Soil compaction

Ungulate animals exert pressure on the soil, which can lead to compaction — an increase in soil density and a decrease in its porosity. Compaction has a number of negative consequences for plants:

  • Reduced water permeability: Compacted soil absorbs water worse, which increases surface runoff and erosion.
  • Worsened aeration: Reduced porosity lowers oxygen content in the soil, which suppresses root respiration and the activity of aerobic microorganisms.
  • Difficulty of root growth: Compacted horizons can be a physical barrier to root penetration deeper, which reduces drought resistance of plants.
  • Reduced fertility: Compaction can slow mineralization of organic matter and cycling of nutrients (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Plant damage

Trampling can directly damage plants:

  • Mechanical damage to aboveground organs: Hooves can break stems, tear off leaves, and damage growing points.
  • Damage to the root system: During trampling, the soil shifts, which can tear roots.
  • Reduced yield: In agrocenoses, trampling can lead to significant yield losses, especially in fields bordering pastures or when livestock graze on fields after harvest.

Positive effects of trampling

However, trampling is not always harmful. In natural ecosystems, moderate grazing can help maintain biodiversity of herbaceous communities:

  • Creation of microhabitats: Trampling creates patches of bare soil, which can be favorable for seed germination of some plant species.
  • Suppression of dominants: Grazing can reduce the abundance of dominant species, giving rare species a chance to persist in the community.
  • Stimulation of regrowth: Moderate eating of aboveground biomass can stimulate the growth of new shoots in some grasses (Weil & Brady, 2017).

In agrocenoses, managed grazing can be used to control weeds and maintain the desired composition of vegetation, as we discussed in the previous section.

Burrowing: Creation of Burrows and Passages

Burrowing is the creation by animals of underground cavities, burrows, passages, and galleries. This type of mechanical impact is closely related to bioturbation but deserves separate consideration, since it has a specific influence on plants.

Impact on soil

  • Increased porosity: Burrows and passages increase the overall porosity of the soil, which improves aeration, water permeability, and drainage.
  • Mixing of horizons: During burrowing, animals mix soil from different horizons, creating heterogeneity of the soil profile.
  • Enrichment with organic matter: Plant residues often fall into burrows, decompose, and enrich the soil with organic matter and nutrients.

Impact on plants

  • Root damage: Burrowing can directly damage plant roots, especially large roots of trees and shrubs.
  • Creation of favorable conditions for germination: Burrows and soil mounds can create microhabitats with favorable conditions for seed germination and seedling growth. For example, mole mounds are often colonized by pioneer plants (Straalen, 2023).
  • Change in water regime: Burrows can serve as channels for water flow, which can both improve and worsen plant water supply depending on context.
  • Access to nutrients: In some cases, plant roots can use burrows to penetrate deep soil horizons rich in nutrients.

Examples:

  • Moles: Create complex systems of passages and mole mounds — soil emissions onto the surface. Mole mounds create patches of fertile soil that are often colonized by plants.
  • Ground squirrels and marmots: Dig deep burrows, throwing significant volumes of soil onto the surface. Their activity creates mosaic vegetation cover.
  • Voles and mice: Create branched systems of passages that improve soil aeration but can damage roots.
  • Birds: Some birds (for example, bank swallows) dig burrows in cliffs, creating habitats for other organisms.

Why Mechanical Interactions Can Be Both Beneficial and Harmful

Mechanical interactions are a clear example of the fact that the sign of an interaction depends on context. The same impact can be beneficial under some conditions and harmful under others.

Beneficial effects of mechanical interactions:

  • Improvement of soil structure: Bioturbation and burrowing increase porosity, aeration, and water permeability of the soil, which is favorable for plant growth.
  • Increased fertility: Mixing of soil and enrichment with organic matter and nutrients increases fertility.
  • Creation of microhabitats: Burrows, soil mounds, and patches of bare soil create a diversity of conditions, which supports plant biodiversity.
  • Stimulation of growth: Moderate trampling and eating can stimulate the growth of new shoots.

Harmful effects of mechanical interactions:

  • Soil compaction: Excessive grazing leads to compaction, reduced water permeability and aeration, which suppresses plant growth.
  • Damage to roots and aboveground organs: Burrowing and trampling can directly damage plants, reducing yield.
  • Soil erosion: Compaction and loss of vegetation cover increase surface runoff and erosion.
  • Reduced biodiversity: Excessive impact can lead to simplification of plant communities.

Significance for the Agronomist

Understanding mechanical interactions has important practical consequences for managing agrocenoses:

1. Grazing management: To prevent soil compaction and plant damage, it is necessary to regulate livestock load, rotate pastures, and avoid grazing on wet soil.

2. Conservation of bioturbators: Earthworms, ants, and other bioturbators must be preserved and maintained in agrocenoses. This requires minimizing tillage, preserving plant residues, and avoiding toxic pesticides.

3. Use of burrowing animals: In some cases, the burrowing activity of animals can be used to improve soil. For example, biological reclamation with the help of earthworms or burrowing rodents can improve the structure of degraded soils.

4. Landscape planning: When planning an agricultural landscape, it is necessary to take into account mechanical interactions. For example, buffer zones along watercourses can prevent erosion caused by trampling.

Brief Reminder About Specific Groups of Animals Participating in Mechanical Interactions

To reinforce the material, let us list the main taxonomic groups of animals participating in mechanical interactions:

  • Earthworms (Lumbricidae, Megascolecidae): Bioturbation, burrowing, creation of coprolites.
  • Ants (Formicidae): Bioturbation, burrowing, creation of nests.
  • Termites (Isoptera): Bioturbation, creation of mounds, burrowing.
  • Rodents (Rodentia): Burrowing, bioturbation, root damage.
  • Moles (Talpidae): Burrowing, creation of mole mounds.
  • Ungulates (Artiodactyla): Trampling, soil compaction, plant damage.
  • Birds (Aves): Burrow digging (bank swallows, some petrels).
  • Insects (Insecta): Burrowing (dung beetles, some wasps and bees).

Mechanical interactions are not merely a “background” for other, more “interesting” interactions. They are a powerful factor determining the structure and functioning of the agrocenosis. Understanding them is necessary for developing sustainable farming systems that minimize negative impacts and maximize the beneficial effects of animal activity.

In the next section, we will consider indirect interactions through soil — how animals influence plants by changing soil processes rather than by acting on plants directly.

8. Indirect Interactions Through Soil

Until now, we have considered animal–plant interactions that can be called direct: an animal eats a plant, pollinates it, transfers its seeds, tramples it, or digs burrows in its immediate vicinity. However, there is another, less obvious but extremely important class of interactions in which animals influence plants indirectly — through changes in soil processes. In this case, the animal does not come into direct contact with the plant, but its activity transforms the environment in which the plant lives and feeds. Understanding these indirect interactions is necessary for a holistic perception of the agrocenosis, since they underlie soil fertility and nutrient cycling.

Soil as an Arena of Indirect Interactions

Soil is not an inert substrate but a living, dynamic system inhabited by an enormous diversity of organisms. One gram of fertile soil can contain billions of bacteria, millions of fungal hyphae, thousands of protozoa, hundreds of nematodes, and dozens of microarthropods (Weil & Brady, 2017). All these organisms are connected by a complex food web, in which animals play the role of regulators and catalysts of key biogeochemical processes.

Indirect interactions through soil can be divided into several main mechanisms:

1. Decomposition of organic matter and mineralization of nutrients.

2. Formation and stabilization of soil aggregates.

3. Change in nutrient availability.

4. Regulation of soil microorganism abundance.

5. Creation of “hotspots” of biological activity.

Let us consider each of these mechanisms in more detail.

Decomposition of Organic Matter and Mineralization of Nutrients

Decomposition of organic matter is a fundamental process that ensures the return of nutrients to the soil and their availability to plants. Although the main “decomposers” are microorganisms (bacteria and fungi), animals play a critical role in stimulating and accelerating this process.

Mechanisms of animal influence on decomposition:

1. Physical fragmentation of plant residues. Detritivorous animals (springtails, mites, earthworms, insect larvae, woodlice) consume plant residues, grinding them into smaller particles. This increases the surface area available for attack by microorganisms. The smaller the particles, the faster they decompose (Weil & Brady, 2017).

2. Transfer and mixing. Animals transfer plant residues from the surface into the soil, where conditions for decomposition may be different (for example, more stable moisture and temperature). Earthworms, ants, and termites actively mix organic matter with mineral particles, creating organomineral complexes, which are the basis of soil fertility (Weil & Brady, 2017).

3. Stimulation of microbial activity. Passing through the digestive tract of an animal, plant residues are mixed with microorganisms and enzymes, which accelerates their decomposition. In addition, animals excrete feces rich in readily available nutrients, which stimulate the growth of microorganisms. Studies show that in the presence of soil animals, the rate of decomposition of plant residues can increase by 20–50% (Weil & Brady, 2017).

4. Regulation of microbial populations. Microbivorous animals (protozoa, nematodes, some mites and springtails) feed on bacteria and fungi, regulating their abundance and activity. Moderate consumption of microbial populations stimulates their growth (the “rejuvenation” effect of the population), which leads to acceleration of organic matter decomposition and mineralization of nutrients (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Mineralization is the process of converting organic forms of nutrients (nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur) into inorganic (mineral) forms available to plants. Animals make a significant contribution to this process:

  • Nitrogen: Microbivorous animals, feeding on bacteria and fungi, release excess nitrogen in the form of ammonium (NH4+). This process is called ammonification. According to estimates, in some ecosystems animals are responsible for 30–40% of the total amount of nitrogen released from organic matter (Weil & Brady, 2017). Earthworms, processing plant residues, also release nitrogen in available form. Studies show that in soils with high earthworm abundance, up to 50–90 kg N/ha per year can be released from organic matter and become available to plants (Weil & Brady, 2017).
  • Phosphorus: Mineralization of phosphorus is also accelerated by animals. Protozoa and nematodes, feeding on bacteria, release phosphates that can be used by plants. In addition, earthworms, processing organic matter, promote the transition of phosphorus into available forms (Weil & Brady, 2017).
  • Sulfur: Mineralization of sulfur occurs similarly to nitrogen. Animals, decomposing organic matter, release sulfates available to plants (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Formation and Stabilization of Soil Aggregates

Soil aggregates are structural units of soil consisting of mineral particles bound by organic matter and biological secretions. Aggregates determine porosity, water permeability, aeration, and erosion resistance of the soil. Animals actively participate in the formation and stabilization of aggregates.

Mechanisms of animal influence on aggregate formation:

1. Earthworm coprolites. Earthworms swallow soil and organic residues, digest them, and excrete coprolites — granular aggregates rich in organic matter and nutrients. Coprolites have high water resistance and mechanical strength, which contributes to the formation of agronomically valuable soil structure. Studies show that earthworm coprolites contain 2–5 times more available forms of nitrogen and phosphorus than surrounding soil (Weil & Brady, 2017).

2. Excrement of other animals. Springtails, mites, woodlice, and other small arthropods also excrete feces that glue mineral particles into microaggregates. These aggregates serve as building blocks for larger macroaggregates formed by plant roots and earthworms (Weil & Brady, 2017).

3. Binding substances. Many animals release mucous substances (mucopolysaccharides) that glue mineral particles. For example, earthworms release mucus that helps form and stabilize aggregates. Nematodes and protozoa also release organic compounds that promote aggregation (Weil & Brady, 2017).

4. Mechanical impact. The burrowing activity of animals (earthworms, ants, termites, rodents) creates pores and passages that improve soil structure. These passages also promote root penetration deeper into the soil and drainage (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Significance for plants:

  • Improvement of water–air regime: Aggregated soil has more large pores, which improves root aeration and water permeability.
  • Increased fertility: Aggregates retain nutrients and water, making them available to plants.
  • Erosion resistance: Stable aggregates are less susceptible to water and wind erosion.
  • Stimulation of root growth: Loose, aggregated soil is easier for roots to penetrate, which promotes plant growth (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Change in Nutrient Availability

Animals can influence the availability of nutrients for plants not only through mineralization but also through changes in chemical conditions in the soil.

Mechanisms:

1. Change in pH. Animal activity can locally change soil acidity. For example, respiration of roots and microorganisms releases CO2, which, reacting with water, forms carbonic acid (H2CO3), lowering pH. Animal excrement can also be acidic or alkaline, depending on its composition. Changes in pH affect the solubility of nutrients and their availability to plants (Weil & Brady, 2017).

2. Chelation. Some animals release chelating compounds that bind metal ions (for example, iron, zinc, manganese), making them more available to plants or, conversely, less available. For example, siderophores released by microorganisms bind iron, but at the same time can make it unavailable to other organisms (Weil & Brady, 2017).

3. Release of nutrients from minerals. The burrowing activity of animals increases the contact area between soil particles and soil solution, which accelerates weathering of minerals and the release of nutrients such as potassium, calcium, and magnesium (Weil & Brady, 2017).

4. Influence on mycorrhiza. Animals that feed on fungi (fungivores) can reduce the abundance of mycorrhizal fungi, which play a key role in supplying plants with phosphorus and other elements. On the other hand, moderate consumption of fungi can stimulate their growth and activity, similar to the “rejuvenation” effect of microbial populations (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Regulation of Soil Microorganism Abundance

Microbivorous animals (protozoa, nematodes, some mites and springtails) are a key link in the soil food web, regulating the abundance and activity of bacteria and fungi. This influence has far-reaching consequences for plants.

Mechanisms:

1. Population control. Microbivores prevent excessive reproduction of bacteria and fungi, which could lead to immobilization of nutrients in microbial biomass. Moderate consumption of microbes releases nutrients in a form available to plants (Weil & Brady, 2017).

2. Stimulation of activity. As already mentioned, consumption of microbial populations stimulates their growth and activity. This is because after consumption of part of the population, the remaining cells receive more nutrients and reproduce faster. This effect is called “microbial rejuvenation” (Weil & Brady, 2017).

3. Change in community composition. Microbivores can selectively feed on certain species of bacteria or fungi, changing the composition of the microbial community. This can affect the functions performed by the community, for example, the decomposition of certain types of organic matter or antagonism against pathogens (Weil & Brady, 2017).

4. Transfer of microorganisms. Animals, moving through the soil, transfer microorganisms on their surface or in the digestive tract, promoting their dispersal and colonization of new substrates. This accelerates decomposition of organic matter and cycling of nutrients (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Significance for plants:

  • Increased nutrient availability: Regulation of microbial populations by animals leads to release of nitrogen, phosphorus, and other elements in a form available to plants.
  • Reduced disease risk: Regulation of pathogenic microorganism abundance by microbivorous animals can reduce the risk of plant diseases.
  • Maintenance of fertility: Regulation of microbial populations contributes to maintaining soil fertility and sustainability of the agrocenosis (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Creation of “Hotspots” of Biological Activity

“Hotspots” are local zones in the soil with increased biological activity. Animals actively create such zones, concentrating organic matter, nutrients, and microorganisms.

Mechanisms:

1. Burrows and passages. Burrows and passages created by animals are often filled with organic residues and excrement, which serve as substrate for microorganisms. Inside burrows, conditions (moisture, temperature, aeration) may be more favorable for microbial activity than in surrounding soil (Weil & Brady, 2017; Straalen, 2023).

2. Coprolites and excrement. Earthworm coprolites and excrement of other animals are “hotspots” of microbial activity, since they contain readily available nutrients and have a porous structure providing good aeration (Weil & Brady, 2017).

3. Rhizosphere. Plant roots release organic compounds that attract microorganisms and animals, creating “hotspots” around roots. Animals, in turn, promote spread of microbes along roots and acceleration of organic matter decomposition in the rhizosphere (Weil & Brady, 2017).

4. Ant and termite “garbage piles.” Ants and termites create “garbage piles” — accumulations of organic waste that are “hotspots” of biological activity and sources of nutrients for plants (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Significance for plants:

  • Increased nutrient availability: “Hotspots” are sources of nutrients that can be used by plants.
  • Stimulation of root growth: Plant roots often actively grow toward “hotspots,” where more nutrients are available.
  • Maintenance of biodiversity: “Hotspots” support diversity of soil organisms, which contributes to sustainability of the agrocenosis (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Why Understanding Indirect Interactions Is Necessary for Understanding the Agrocenosis

Indirect interactions through soil are the “invisible” part of the iceberg of animal–plant interactions. Although they are not as obvious as, for example, a caterpillar eating leaves or a bee pollinating, their importance for the functioning of the agrocenosis is enormous.

1. Soil fertility is the basis of productivity

Soil fertility is the ability of soil to provide plants with nutrients, water, and air. Animals, through decomposition of organic matter, mineralization of nutrients, formation of aggregates, and regulation of microbial populations, directly influence fertility. Without their activity, soil quickly becomes depleted and degrades.

2. Resilience to stresses

Agrocenoses in which the diversity of soil animals is preserved are more resilient to stresses such as drought, floods, and erosion. Diverse soil fauna provides functional redundancy — the ability of the ecosystem to perform its functions even when some species are lost. This makes the agrocenosis more stable and predictable (Weil & Brady, 2017).

3. Reducing dependence on external inputs

Understanding indirect interactions makes it possible to reduce dependence on external inputs such as mineral fertilizers and pesticides. For example, stimulating the activity of earthworms and microbivores can increase nutrient availability without applying fertilizers. Preserving antagonistic microorganisms can reduce the risk of plant diseases without using fungicides (Weil & Brady, 2017).

4. Ecosystem services

Soil animals provide ecosystem services that have economic value:

  • Decomposition of organic waste: Animals accelerate the decomposition of manure, compost, and plant residues, turning them into humus and nutrients.
  • Carbon sequestration: Animal activity contributes to accumulation of organic carbon in the soil, which helps mitigate climate change.
  • Water purification: Aggregated soil filters water, removing pollutants.
  • Biological control: Regulation of microbial populations by animals can reduce the abundance of pathogens (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Brief Reminder About Specific Groups of Animals Participating in Indirect Interactions

To reinforce the material, let us list the main taxonomic groups of animals participating in indirect interactions through soil:

  • Earthworms (Lumbricidae, Megascolecidae): Decomposition, mineralization, aggregate formation, creation of “hotspots.”
  • Enchytraeids (Enchytraeidae): Decomposition, mineralization, aggregate formation.
  • Protozoa (Protozoa): Regulation of bacterial populations, nitrogen mineralization.
  • Nematodes (Nematoda): Regulation of microbial populations, mineralization, dispersal of microorganisms.
  • Springtails (Collembola): Decomposition, regulation of fungal populations, aggregate formation.
  • Mites (Acari): Decomposition, regulation of microbial populations, aggregate formation.
  • Woodlice (Isopoda): Decomposition, aggregate formation.
  • Ants (Formicidae): Bioturbation, creation of “hotspots,” dispersal of microorganisms.
  • Termites (Isoptera): Bioturbation, decomposition, creation of “hotspots.”
  • Rodents (Rodentia): Bioturbation, soil mixing, creation of “hotspots.”
  • Insect larvae (Insecta): Decomposition, mineralization, aggregate formation.

Indirect interactions through soil are the foundation on which sustainable and productive crop production is built. Understanding them makes it possible to manage the agrocenosis not through fighting individual “pests” but through maintaining and stimulating natural processes underlying soil fertility.

In the next section, we will consider another type of interaction that has enormous practical importance for plant protection — interactions through disease vectors.

9. Interactions Through Disease Vectors

Until now, we have considered animal–plant interactions that could be directly observed: eating leaves, pollinating flowers, transferring seeds, digging burrows. However, there is another, less obvious but extremely important type of interaction in which animals influence plants indirectly — through the transmission of pathogens. In this case, the animal itself may not cause significant direct damage to the plant (or may cause minimal damage), but its role as a vector (transmitter) of phytopathogens can lead to catastrophic consequences for the harvest. Understanding these interactions is necessary for developing effective plant protection strategies.

Vector Interactions: Definition and Place in the System

Vector interactions are a type of interaction in which an animal (vector) transmits a pathogenic organism (virus, bacterium, mycoplasma, nematode) from an infected plant to a healthy one. From the point of view of classification by sign, this interaction can be regarded as antagonism (+, −) between the vector and the plant, but with an important caveat: the vector benefits not from the plant itself (for example, not from its tissues), but from the pathogen or from the conditions that the pathogen creates. The plant experiences double damage: from the vector itself (if it feeds on its tissues) and from the pathogen that the vector transmits.

Vector interactions can be represented as a three-component system:

1. Pathogen — the causative agent of the disease (virus, bacterium, mycoplasma, nematode).

2. Vector — the animal transmitting the pathogen.

3. Host plant — the cultivated or wild plant affected by the pathogen.

Unlike direct phytophages, which cause damage by consuming plant tissues, vectors often cause damage indirectly — through transmission of the pathogen. For example, an aphid feeding on plant sap can acquire a virus from an infected plant and transmit it to a healthy one, even if the aphid itself causes minimal direct damage. In this case, damage from the pathogen can many times exceed damage from the vector itself (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017).

Main Groups of Phytopathogen Vectors

Representatives of various taxonomic groups of animals act as vectors of phytopathogens. The most important of them are insects with piercing-sucking mouthparts and nematodes.

1. Insect vectors

Insects are the most numerous and diverse group of phytopathogen vectors. Their role in transmitting viruses, mycoplasmas, and bacteria is enormous. Key groups of insect vectors include:

  • Aphids (Aphididae): Aphids are among the most important vectors of plant viruses. They transmit more than 300 virus species, including such dangerous ones as cucumber mosaic virus (CMV), potato virus Y (PVY), potato leafroll virus (PLRV), and many others (Gullan & Cranston, 2014; Czosnek et al., 2017). Aphids transmit viruses in a nonpersistent (stylet-borne) manner: the virus attaches to the stylet and is transferred to a healthy plant within seconds or minutes after acquisition. Aphids can also transmit viruses in a persistent manner, in which the virus passes through the digestive tract, enters the hemolymph, and then the salivary glands, from where it is transmitted during feeding. Persistent transmission requires more time, but the insect remains infectious for many days or its entire life (Hogenhout et al., 2008).
  • Whiteflies (Aleyrodidae): Whiteflies, especially Bemisia tabaci, are vectors of begomoviruses (Begomovirus) — a group of viruses causing enormous yield losses in tomatoes, cucumbers, cotton, and other crops. The most famous example is tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV), which is transmitted by whiteflies in a circulative persistent manner: the virus passes through the digestive tract, hemolymph, and salivary glands, and the insect remains infectious for its entire life (Czosnek et al., 2017). Whiteflies also transmit criniviruses (Crinivirus), such as tomato infectious chlorosis virus (TICV) and tomato chlorosis virus (ToCV), which cause yellowing of leaves and reduced yield (Czosnek et al., 2017).
  • Thrips (Thysanoptera): Thrips, especially Frankliniella occidentalis, are vectors of tospoviruses (Tospovirus), including tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) — one of the most dangerous viruses of tomatoes, peppers, and other crops. TSWV is transmitted in a propagative persistent manner: the virus not only passes through the digestive tract and salivary glands but also multiplies in the body of the thrips. Thrips acquire the virus at the larval stage and transmit it as adults (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017).
  • Leafhoppers (Cicadellidae): Leafhoppers are vectors of mycoplasmas and viruses, such as maize dwarf mosaic virus (MDMV) and potato vein necrosis virus (PVY). They transmit pathogens in a persistent or semipersistent manner, depending on the specific pathogen (Hogenhout et al., 2008).
  • Psyllids (Psylloidea): Psyllids are vectors of phytoplasmas (for example, citrus phytoplasma) and bacteria (for example, Candidatus Liberibacter — the causative agent of citrus HLB). They transmit pathogens in a persistent manner, feeding on phloem (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • True bugs (Heteroptera): Some bugs, for example Lygus spp., can transmit bacteria and phytoplasmas, although their role as vectors is less significant than that of the groups listed above (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

2. Nematode vectors

Nematodes are the second most important group of phytopathogen vectors after insects. Unlike insects, nematodes transmit exclusively viruses, but their role in the spread of viral plant diseases is enormous.

Key groups of nematode vectors:

  • Root nematodes (Longidoridae): The genera Xiphinema and Longidorus are vectors of nepoviruses (Nepovirus) — a group of viruses affecting a wide range of crops, including grapes, raspberries, tomatoes, and fruit trees. For example, Xiphinema index transmits grapevine fanleaf virus (GFLV), which causes enormous damage to viticulture (Weil & Brady, 2017; Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Stubby-root nematodes (Trichodoridae): The genera Trichodorus and Paratrichodorus are vectors of tobraviruses (Tobravirus), including pea early browning virus (PEBV) and tobacco rattle virus (TRV). These viruses affect many vegetable and ornamental crops (Weil & Brady, 2017).
  • Root-knot nematodes (Meloidogynidae): Although root-knot nematodes (Meloidogyne spp.) are themselves serious phytophages, they can also aggravate viral infections by creating wounds on roots through which viruses enter the plant. Direct transmission of viruses by root-knot nematodes has not been proven, but their role as “gates” for infection is significant (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Mechanisms of virus transmission by nematodes:

Nematodes transmit viruses in a persistent or semipersistent manner:

  • In semipersistent transmission, the virus attaches to the nematode’s stylet and is transferred to a healthy plant. The nematode remains infectious for several hours or days.
  • In persistent transmission, the virus passes through the nematode’s digestive tract, enters the hemolymph, and then the salivary glands. The nematode remains infectious for many days or its entire life, and in some cases the virus is transmitted to the nematode’s offspring (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Mechanisms of Pathogen Transmission: Types and Classification

The mode of pathogen transmission by a vector is of enormous importance for understanding the epidemiology of diseases and developing plant protection strategies. In phytopathology, several main types of transmission are distinguished, which differ in the time during which the vector remains infectious and in whether the pathogen passes through the vector’s body.

1. Nonpersistent (stylet-borne) transmission

  • Mechanism: The pathogen (usually a virus) attaches to the stylet (piercing proboscis) of the vector during feeding on an infected plant. During the next feeding on a healthy plant, the virus is transmitted together with saliva or on the surface of the stylet.
  • Time: The vector acquires the virus in several seconds and transmits it in several seconds or minutes. However, the vector loses the ability to transmit the virus very quickly — within several minutes or hours.
  • Examples: Most viruses transmitted by aphids (CMV, PVY) are transmitted in a nonpersistent manner.
  • Significance for management: Since the vector loses the virus quickly, to control nonpersistent viruses it is important to prevent feeding of vectors on the crop, for example, with insecticides, repellents, or physical barriers. However, since transmission occurs very quickly, insecticides may not manage to kill the vector before it transmits the virus (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

2. Semipersistent (gut-borne) transmission

  • Mechanism: The pathogen passes through the vector’s digestive tract but does not penetrate into the hemolymph. It accumulates in the intestine or salivary glands and is transmitted during feeding.
  • Time: The vector acquires the pathogen in several minutes or hours and remains infectious for several days. After molting, the vector loses the ability to transmit the pathogen.
  • Examples: Some viruses transmitted by thrips and leafhoppers (for example, viruses transmitted by leafhoppers).
  • Significance for management: Since the vector remains infectious for several days, insecticides can be effective in reducing vector abundance and, accordingly, the spread of the disease (Hogenhout et al., 2008).

3. Persistent (circulative) transmission

  • Mechanism: The pathogen passes through the vector’s digestive tract, enters the hemolymph, then the salivary glands, and is transmitted during feeding. The pathogen does not multiply in the vector’s body but accumulates in it.
  • Time: The vector acquires the pathogen in several hours or days (latent period), after which it remains infectious for its entire life. The pathogen persists in the vector even after molting.
  • Examples: Viruses transmitted by whiteflies (TYLCV), aphids (PLRV), leafhoppers (maize dwarf mosaic virus).
  • Significance for management: Since the vector remains infectious for life, disease control requires long-term control of vector abundance. Insecticides can be effective, but their use must be strategic and timely (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017).

4. Propagative (multiplying) transmission

  • Mechanism: The pathogen not only passes through the vector’s body but also multiplies in it. This is the most complex type of transmission, in which the vector becomes a reservoir of the pathogen.
  • Time: The latent period can be from several days to several weeks. The vector remains infectious for life, and in some cases the pathogen is transmitted transovarially (through eggs) to the offspring.
  • Examples: Tospoviruses transmitted by thrips (TSWV); some viruses transmitted by leafhoppers and psyllids.
  • Significance for management: Since the pathogen multiplies in the vector and can be transmitted to offspring, disease control requires an integrated approach, including vector control, use of resistant varieties, and possibly quarantine measures (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017).

Examples of Vector Interactions in Agrocenoses

Let us consider several specific examples illustrating the enormous importance of vector interactions for agriculture.

1. Aphids and viral diseases

Aphids are among the most dangerous virus vectors in temperate and tropical regions. For example:

  • Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV): Affects more than 750 plant species, including cucumbers, tomatoes, peppers, lettuce, and many others. It is transmitted by more than 60 aphid species in a nonpersistent manner. The virus does not persist in tomato seeds but can be transferred from weeds and other crops (Czosnek et al., 2017).
  • Potato virus Y (PVY): Affects potatoes, tomatoes, and peppers. Transmitted by aphids in a nonpersistent manner. Infection can destroy up to 80% of the harvest with early infection (Czosnek et al., 2017).
  • Potato leafroll virus (PLRV): Transmitted by aphids in a persistent manner. Causes leaf curling, reduced yield, and quality of tubers (Czosnek et al., 2017).

2. Whiteflies and begomoviruses

The whitefly Bemisia tabaci is one of the most dangerous pests in tropical and subtropical regions. It transmits begomoviruses, which cause:

  • Tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV): Affects tomatoes, causing yellowing, leaf curling, dwarfism, and complete loss of harvest. Transmitted by whiteflies in a circulative persistent manner. Infection can destroy up to 100% of the harvest (Czosnek et al., 2017).
  • Tomato mosaic virus (ToMoV): Affects tomatoes in the USA and other regions. Transmitted by whiteflies in a circulative persistent manner (Czosnek et al., 2017).

3. Thrips and tospoviruses

The thrips Frankliniella occidentalis is the main vector of tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV), which affects more than 800 plant species, including tomatoes, peppers, lettuce, and ornamental crops. TSWV is transmitted in a propagative persistent manner: the virus multiplies in the thrips body and is transmitted to offspring. Infection can lead to complete loss of harvest (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017).

4. Nematodes and nepoviruses

The nematode Xiphinema index is a vector of grapevine fanleaf virus (GFLV), which causes degradation of vineyards and reduced yield. The virus is transmitted by nematodes in a persistent manner and persists in the soil for many years. Control of GFLV requires destruction of infected plants and disinfection of soil, which makes this disease one of the most difficult to control (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Why Understanding Vector Interactions Is Important for Plant Protection

Vector interactions are a key factor in the epidemiology of many plant diseases. Understanding them is necessary for developing effective and sustainable plant protection strategies.

1. Vectors determine disease spread

Without a vector, many pathogens could not spread from plant to plant. For example, viruses transmitted by aphids, whiteflies, or nematodes cannot move independently over long distances. Vectors provide horizontal transmission — from plant to plant — and vertical transmission — from generation to generation (through seeds or transovarially). Understanding the ecology of vectors — their life cycles, feeding preferences, seasonal dynamics — is necessary for predicting outbreaks of diseases and developing timely control measures (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017).

2. Type of transmission determines control strategy

As we have seen, the type of transmission (nonpersistent, semipersistent, persistent, propagative) determines how quickly the vector loses infectiousness and how long it remains dangerous. This, in turn, determines the strategy of control:

  • For nonpersistent viruses, it is important to prevent feeding of vectors on the crop, since transmission occurs very quickly.
  • For persistent and propagative viruses, it is important to reduce vector abundance on a long-term basis, since they remain infectious for life.
  • For propagative viruses that multiply in the vector, it is necessary to take into account the possibility of transovarial transmission and reservoirs of the pathogen in vector populations (Hogenhout et al., 2008).

3. Vectors can be “gates” for secondary infections

Even if the vector does not transmit a pathogen directly, its feeding can create wounds on the plant through which bacteria and fungi penetrate. For example, nematodes damaging roots create gates for fungal infections. Thus, vectors can aggravate damage from other pathogens (Weil & Brady, 2017).

4. Vector management is part of integrated plant protection

Vector interactions are an example of why integrated pest management (IPM) must take into account the entire network of ecological interactions, and not only direct pests. Vector management requires an integrated approach:

  • Monitoring vector abundance.
  • Forecasting disease outbreaks based on vector ecology.
  • Use of resistant varieties.
  • Application of insecticides timely and strategically.
  • Conservation of natural enemies of vectors (predators, parasitoids).
  • Quarantine measures to prevent introduction of new vectors and pathogens (Pedigo, 2002; Czosnek et al., 2017).

Brief Reminder About Specific Groups of Vectors

To reinforce the material, let us list the main taxonomic groups of animal vectors of phytopathogens:

1) Insects (Insecta):

  • Hemiptera: Aphids (Aphididae), whiteflies (Aleyrodidae), leafhoppers (Cicadellidae), psyllids (Psylloidea), true bugs (Heteroptera), mealybugs and scale insects (Coccoidea).
  • Thysanoptera: Thrips (Thripidae).
  • Coleoptera: Some beetles (for example, Scolytus — vector of Dutch elm disease).

2) Nematodes (Nematoda):

  • Longidoridae: Xiphinema, Longidorus — vectors of nepoviruses.
  • Trichodoridae: Trichodorus, Paratrichodorus — vectors of tobraviruses.

3) Mites (Acari): Some mites (for example, Brevipalpus — vector of citrus viruses).

4) Fungi (Fungi): Some fungi (for example, Olpidium — vector of viruses) — although these are not animals, they are also vectors and deserve mention for completeness.

Vector interactions are a clear example of how animals can influence plants indirectly, through the transmission of pathogens. Understanding them is necessary for effective and sustainable plant protection, especially in the context of climate change, which can affect the spread of vectors and pathogens. In the next section, we will consider the complexity of interactions in the agrocenosis in order to understand how all the considered types of interactions are connected with one another.

10. Complexity of Interactions in the Agrocenosis

Throughout the previous sections, we have consistently examined the main types of interactions between animals and plants: phytophagy, pollination, zoochory, mechanical impacts, indirect interactions through soil, and vector interactions. However, in a real agrocenosis these interactions do not exist in isolation. They form a complex, dynamic network in which each component influences the others, and the final effect on yield is often the result of interaction of interactions. Understanding this complexity is the key to developing effective and sustainable strategies for managing the agrocenosis.

Why Interactions Cannot Be Considered in Isolation

The traditional agronomic approach often considers each interaction separately: there are pests to be controlled; there are pollinators to be attracted; there are soil organisms to be cared for. However, such a reductionist view overlooks the emergent properties of the system — properties that arise from the interaction of components and cannot be predicted based on analysis of each component separately (Gliessman, 2007).

Let us consider several examples demonstrating why an isolated approach can lead to erroneous decisions.

Example 1: Aphids — “pests,” “bait,” and “vectors” simultaneously

Aphids (Aphididae) are traditionally regarded as pests, since they feed on plant sap, weaken plants, and can transmit viruses. However, their role in the agrocenosis is not limited to this function:

  • Aphids as phytophages: They consume a significant amount of plant sap, which can reduce yield. However, at moderate abundance their direct impact on yield may be insignificant.
  • Aphids as mutualists with ants: Many ant species enter into mutualistic relationships with aphids, protecting them from predators and parasitoids in exchange for sweet secretions (honeydew). In this case, ants promote aphid reproduction, aggravating their harmfulness (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Aphids as virus vectors: As we discussed in the previous section, aphids are the main vectors of plant viruses. Damage from viral infection can many times exceed damage from direct aphid feeding (Hogenhout et al., 2008; Czosnek et al., 2017).
  • Aphids as a food base for entomophages: Aphids serve as food for numerous predators (ladybirds, lacewings, hoverflies) and as hosts for parasitoids (ichneumon wasps). These entomophages, in turn, regulate the abundance not only of aphids but also of other phytophages. Thus, preserving a moderate aphid population can support populations of beneficial insects in the agrocenosis (Pedigo, 2002; Shameer & Hardy, 2024).

If an agronomist applies an insecticide against aphids, he may not only destroy the aphids themselves but also deprive entomophages of their food base, which will lead to an outbreak of other pests. In addition, the insecticide may not manage to prevent virus transmission, since nonpersistent viruses are transmitted within seconds (Hogenhout et al., 2008). Thus, the simple solution “destroy aphids” can have complex and unpredictable consequences for the entire system.

Example 2: Cascading effects in the soil food web

The soil food web is another example of the complexity of interactions. Let us consider a cascading effect arising from a change in the abundance of one group of organisms:

  • Protozoa feed on bacteria, regulating their abundance and stimulating their activity. Moderate consumption of bacteria by protozoa accelerates decomposition of organic matter and release of nitrogen in a form available to plants (Weil & Brady, 2017).
  • Nematodes feed on protozoa and bacteria. If nematode abundance decreases (for example, due to the use of nematicides), this can lead to an increase in protozoan abundance, which, in turn, will reduce bacterial abundance and slow down decomposition of organic matter and nitrogen mineralization. As a result, nitrogen availability for plants will decrease, and yield may fall, even if the direct effect of the nematicide on the plant was neutral (Weil & Brady, 2017).
  • Mycorrhizal fungi (Glomeromycota) form mutualistic relationships with plant roots, improving plant supply of phosphorus and water. Fungivores (springtails, mites) feed on the mycelium of mycorrhizal fungi. Moderate consumption of fungi can stimulate their growth, but excessive consumption reduces the effectiveness of mycorrhiza and worsens plant nutrition (Weil & Brady, 2017).

This example shows that impact on one group of organisms can cascade through the entire food web, leading to unexpected consequences for plants.

Example 3: Interaction of pollination and phytophagy

Pollination and phytophagy are often considered independent processes. However, they can be connected through shared resources and shared participants:

  • Flowers as food for phytophages: Many phytophages (beetles, caterpillars, aphids) feed on flowers, buds, and nectar, reducing their attractiveness to pollinators and reducing pollination. For example, thrips feeding on flowers can damage anthers and stigmas, which reduces fruit set (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Pollinators as food for predators: Pollinators (bees, butterflies, hoverflies) can become prey for predators (spiders, birds, dragonflies) that concentrate around flowers. This can reduce pollinator abundance and worsen pollination (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Competition for nectar: Different pollinator species can compete for nectar, and dominance of one species (for example, the honey bee) can reduce pollination efficiency by other species (Garibaldi et al., 2013).

Thus, managing phytophages (for example, applying insecticides) can unintentionally affect pollinators, and vice versa. An integrated approach requires taking these relationships into account.

The Concept of “Quality” of Interactions: From Binary Oppositions to a Continuum

The traditional division of interactions into mutualism (+, +), antagonism (+, −), and commensalism (+, 0) is a simplification. In reality, interactions often change in time and space, passing from one category to another. This phenomenon is called context-dependent interactions (Shameer & Hardy, 2024).

Examples of context dependence:

  • Ants and aphids: The interaction can be mutualistic (ants protect aphids, aphids give honeydew), but can become antagonistic if ants “milk” aphids too intensively, reducing their survival.
  • Birds and plants: Birds can be mutualists (disperse seeds), antagonists (peck fruits), or commensals (use plants as shelter), depending on species, season, and availability of alternative foods (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Mycorrhizal fungi and plants: The interaction is mutualistic at low phosphorus content in the soil but can become parasitic (the fungus receives sugars but does not give the plant phosphorus) at high phosphorus content (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Thus, the sign of an interaction is not a fixed property of a species but a dynamic characteristic depending on conditions. This means that management of the agrocenosis must be adaptive and context-dependent.

Functional Groups and Ecosystem Services: A Holistic Approach

To manage complex interactions in the agrocenosis, it is necessary to move from a taxonomic approach (management of individual species) to a functional approach (management of functional groups and ecosystem services) (Gliessman, 2007).

A functional group is a group of organisms performing a similar ecological function in a community, regardless of their taxonomic position. For example:

  • Pollinators: All animals participating in pollination (bees, bumblebees, hoverflies, butterflies, birds, bats).
  • Entomophages: All animals feeding on phytophagous insects (predatory beetles, spiders, parasitoids, birds).
  • Detritivores: All animals decomposing dead organic matter (earthworms, springtails, mites, woodlice).
  • Bioturbators: All animals mixing soil (earthworms, ants, termites, rodents).

Managing functional groups makes it possible to maintain the ecosystem services they provide without focusing on individual species. For example, preserving pollinator diversity (and not only the honey bee) increases the reliability of pollination (Garibaldi et al., 2013; IPBES, 2016). Maintaining entomophage diversity reduces the risk of phytophage outbreaks (Pedigo, 2002; Shameer & Hardy, 2024). Stimulating the activity of detritivores and bioturbators improves soil fertility (Weil & Brady, 2017).

Ecosystem services are the benefits that people receive from the functioning of ecosystems. In the context of the agrocenosis, the key ecosystem services provided by animals include:

  • Pollination: Ensures yield formation in 75% of crops (IPBES, 2016).
  • Biological control: Regulates pest abundance (Pedigo, 2002).
  • Decomposition of organic matter and mineralization: Ensures nutrient availability (Weil & Brady, 2017).
  • Formation of soil structure: Improves water–air regime and erosion resistance (Weil & Brady, 2017).
  • Seed dispersal: Supports biodiversity and ecosystem restoration (Godó et al., 2022).
  • Regulation of water regime: Affects infiltration and runoff (Weil & Brady, 2017).

The holistic approach to managing the agrocenosis recognizes that all these services are interconnected and that impact on one of them can affect others. For example, the use of pesticides reduces the abundance not only of pests but also of pollinators, entomophages, detritivores, and bioturbators, which undermines several ecosystem services at once (Pedigo, 2002; Goulson et al., 2015).

Examples of Complex Interactions in Agrocenoses

Let us consider several specific examples demonstrating the complexity of interactions in real agrocenoses.

1. Polycultures and complexity of interactions

Polycultures are systems in which several crop species are grown simultaneously. Polycultures demonstrate the complexity of interactions:

  • Reduced phytophage abundance: In polycultures, phytophages have difficulty finding host plants because they are “diluted” by other species. This reduces their abundance and damage (Gliessman, 2007).
  • Attraction of entomophages: Plant diversity attracts diverse entomophages that regulate phytophage abundance (Shameer & Hardy, 2024).
  • Improved pollination: Flower diversity attracts diverse pollinators, increasing pollination reliability (IPBES, 2016).
  • Improved soil processes: Different crops have different root systems and nutrient requirements, which improves resource use and supports soil organism diversity (Weil & Brady, 2017).

2. Rice–fish systems

Rice–fish systems are an example of integrated management in which the complexity of interactions is used to increase productivity and sustainability:

  • Fish control weeds: Herbivorous fish (grass carp) eat aquatic weeds, reducing their competition with rice (Pillay, 2005).
  • Fish control pests: Fish eat insect larvae, reducing their abundance (Pillay, 2005).
  • Fish fertilize the soil: Fish excrement enriches water and soil with nutrients, increasing fertility (Pillay, 2005).
  • Rice provides an environment for fish: Rice paddies create a favorable environment for fish, protecting them from predators and providing food (Pillay, 2005).
  • Additional source of income: Fish cultivation gives the farmer an additional source of protein and income (Pillay, 2005).

3. Push-Pull Systems

Push-pull systems are an innovative approach to pest management based on the integrated use of repellent plants and trap plants:

  • "Push" (repellence): Repellent plants (for example, Desmodium) release volatile substances that repel pests (for example, the stem borer) from the main crop (Gliessman, 2007).
  • "Pull" (attraction): Trap plants (for example, Napier grass) attract pests, diverting them from the main crop. Pests lay eggs on the traps, but the larvae do not survive (Gliessman, 2007).
  • Combined effect: Push-pull systems reduce pest abundance, increase yields, and reduce the need for insecticides. They also suppress weeds (for example, Striga) and improve soil fertility (Gliessman, 2007).

Why Understanding the Entire Network of Interactions Is the Basis of Integrated Plant Protection

Integrated pest management (IPM) is an approach to pest management based on comprehensive consideration of ecological interactions (Pedigo, 2002). IPM recognizes that:

1. Pests are not "enemies" but components of the ecosystem. Their abundance is regulated by natural enemies, competition, and resources.

2. The economic threshold is the level of pest abundance at which economic damage exceeds the cost of protective measures. Below this threshold, the pest may be present in the agrocenosis without causing significant harm, and may even be beneficial by supporting populations of entomophages (Pedigo, 2002).

3. Complexity requires comprehensive solutions. Instead of applying a single broad-spectrum insecticide, IPM offers a combination of methods: resistant varieties, crop rotation, biological control, cultural practices, monitoring, and, only when necessary, selective pesticides (Pedigo, 2002).

4. Conservation of biodiversity is the key to sustainability. The diversity of plants and animals in the agrocenosis ensures functional redundancy—the ability of the ecosystem to perform its functions even when some species are lost (Gliessman, 2007; Shameer & Hardy, 2024).

Brief Reminder About the Key Concepts of Complexity

To consolidate the material, let us list the key concepts that must be taken into account when analyzing the complexity of interactions in an agrocenosis:

  • Context dependence: The sign of an interaction (mutualism, antagonism, commensalism) depends on conditions (species, season, availability of resources).
  • Cascading effects: An impact on one group of organisms spreads through the food web, leading to unexpected consequences.
  • Functional groups: Managing functional groups (rather than individual species) makes it possible to maintain ecosystem services.
  • Ecosystem services: The benefits that humans receive from the functioning of ecosystems (pollination, biocontrol, decomposition, soil formation).
  • Functional redundancy: The diversity of species performing similar functions increases the stability of the ecosystem.
  • Economic threshold: The level of pest abundance at which protective measures are necessary.
  • Holistic approach: Taking into account all interactions and their interconnections when making decisions.

Significance for the Agronomist: Why This Is Important

Understanding the complexity of interactions is of fundamental importance for practical agronomy. It makes it possible to:

1. Avoid erroneous decisions based on simplified ideas about "harmful" and "beneficial" organisms.

2. Predict the consequences of management decisions for the entire ecosystem, not only for individual components.

3. Develop sustainable management strategies that minimize negative impacts on the environment and support ecosystem services.

4. Increase the economic efficiency of production by reducing the costs of external inputs (pesticides, fertilizers) and increasing yields.

5. Ensure food security and the sustainability of agrocenoses under conditions of climate change and other global challenges.

Complexity is not an abstract concept but a practical reality that every agronomist encounters. Ignoring this reality leads to reduced yields, soil degradation, loss of biodiversity, and economic losses. Understanding complexity, by contrast, opens the path to sustainable and efficient farming based on the use of natural ecological processes.

In the next section we will examine the practical consequences of understanding the complexity of interactions for the agronomist and discuss how this knowledge can be applied to develop sustainable agrocenoses.

11. Significance for the Agronomist

We have come to the concluding section of our lecture. Over the previous ten sections we have successively examined the diversity of interactions between animals and cultivated plants: from antagonistic phytophagy to mutualistic pollination, from mechanical bioturbation to indirect effects through soil processes and vector interactions. We have seen that an agrocenosis is not simply a field with plants but a complex ecosystem in which animals play many roles, often simultaneously and ambiguously.

Now the key question arises: what does all this mean for the practicing agronomist? How can this knowledge be applied in everyday work? Why is understanding the ecology of "animal—plant" interactions not an academic exercise but a necessary condition for making effective and sustainable management decisions?

In this section we will formulate three fundamental principles that every agronomist must assimilate and show how they are connected with practice.

Principle 1: One Cannot Make Decisions While Ignoring Animals

The first and perhaps most important principle is that any agronomic decision must be made taking into account the animal population of the agrocenosis. Ignoring animals—whether their presence, their role, or the consequences of impacting them—leads to unpredictable and often negative consequences.

Why is this important in practice?

Let us consider several examples showing how ignoring animals leads to mistakes.

Example 1: Application of Broad-Spectrum Insecticides

The traditional approach to controlling insect pests often consists in applying broad-spectrum insecticides that destroy "all insects" in the field. However, such a decision ignores several key facts:

  • Insecticides destroy not only pests but also beneficial insects. Pollinators (bees, bumblebees, hoverflies), entomophages (ladybugs, lacewings, ichneumon wasps), and detritivores (springtails, mites) also die. This reduces the ecosystem services they provide (Pedigo, 2002; Goulson et al., 2015).
  • Destruction of entomophages leads to pest outbreaks. After the application of an insecticide, pest abundance may recover faster than the abundance of their natural enemies, which leads to a secondary outbreak, often more serious than the initial one. This phenomenon is called "pest resurgence" (Pedigo, 2002).
  • Insecticides can destroy pollinators, reducing yield. For example, the application of neonicotinoids during flowering can reduce bee abundance and worsen pollination, which will lead to yield loss even in the absence of pests (Goulson et al., 2015; IPBES, 2016).

Thus, the decision to "spray the field with an insecticide" without taking into account its impact on the entire animal community can lead to the opposite result—reduced yield and degradation of the agrocenosis.

Example 2: Destruction of "Weeds" with Herbicides

Herbicides are widely used to destroy weed plants. However, weeds are not simply "competitors" of cultivated plants. They can perform important ecological functions:

  • Weeds as a source of nectar and pollen for pollinators. Many weed plants (for example, cornflowers, poppies, daisies) are important food sources for bees, bumblebees, and other pollinators, especially during periods when cultivated plants are not flowering (Goulson et al., 2015; IPBES, 2016).
  • Weeds as shelter for entomophages. Weed plants create microhabitats for predators and parasitoids that regulate pest abundance (Shameer & Hardy, 2024).
  • Weeds as a source of organic matter. Some weeds can improve the soil; for example, leguminous weeds fix nitrogen (Weil & Brady, 2017).

The complete destruction of weeds with herbicides can deprive pollinators and entomophages of their food base and shelters, which will reduce their abundance and worsen ecosystem services. As a result, yield may decline even in the absence of direct competitors (Gliessman, 2007).

Example 3: Ignoring Soil Fauna

Soil tillage (plowing, cultivation) is often regarded as a neutral practice unrelated to animals. However, soil tillage destroys earthworm tunnels, disrupts mycorrhizal networks, and disturbs the habitats of soil organisms. This reduces the abundance and activity of bioturbators and detritivores, which leads to deterioration of soil structure, reduced water infiltration, accelerated erosion, and slowed decomposition of organic matter and mineralization of nutrients (Weil & Brady, 2017). In the long term this reduces soil fertility and requires ever greater external inputs (fertilizers) to maintain yield.

Conclusion: The agronomist cannot ignore animals, since they are an integral part of the agrocenosis. Any decision—application of pesticides, soil tillage, choice of crop, planning of crop rotation—must take into account its consequences for the entire animal community.

Principle 2: "Harmful" and "Beneficial" Are Not Absolute Categories

The second fundamental principle is that dividing animals into "harmful" and "beneficial" is a simplification that can lead to erroneous decisions. As we have seen throughout the lecture, the sign of an interaction (mutualism, antagonism, commensalism) depends on the context: on the species of animal, its stage of development, the physiological state of the plant, environmental conditions, and the presence of other organisms.

Why is this important in practice?

Example 1: Bees—Pollinators and "Destroyers"

Honey bees are classic mutualists, pollinating 75% of crops (IPBES, 2016). However, in some situations bees can cause damage:

  • Damage to flowers. When collecting pollen, bees can damage anthers and stigmas, reducing fruit set (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • "Nectar theft." Some bees puncture the corolla from the side without performing pollination (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Eating fruits. In some cases bees can feed on ripening fruits (for example, grapes), reducing yield (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Thus, the same animal can be both beneficial (as a pollinator) and harmful (as a consumer of the harvest). The net effect depends on the balance of these roles, which in turn is determined by abundance, species composition, and the availability of alternative foods.

Example 2: Ants—Predators, "Herdsmen," and Phytophages

Ants are an extremely diverse group. Many species are predators that destroy insect pests, which makes them beneficial (Pedigo, 2002). However, the same ants can:

  • Protect aphids from predators and parasitoids, promoting pest reproduction (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Feed on plant tissues (leafcutter ants), causing direct damage (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).
  • Create "trash heaps" that can attract pests (Weil & Brady, 2017).

The net effect of ants on the agrocenosis depends on the species, abundance, and context. The simple decision to "destroy the ants" can deprive the agrocenosis of beneficial predators and lead to an outbreak of other pests.

Example 3: Birds—Entomophages and Consumers of the Harvest

Birds eat insect pests, reducing their abundance (Pedigo, 2002). However, the same birds can peck at ripening fruits and seeds, causing direct damage to the harvest (Godó et al., 2022). The net effect depends on the species of birds, the season, and the availability of alternative foods. Destroying all birds in a field can lead to an outbreak of insect pests that were previously controlled by these birds.

What does this mean for the agronomist?

The agronomist must abandon simplified labels of "harmful" and "beneficial" and move to context-dependent analysis. Instead of the question "How do I destroy this pest?" one should ask:

  • What is the abundance of this species? Does it exceed the economic threshold?
  • What role does this species play in the ecosystem? Is it only a phytophage, or also a pollinator, entomophage, detritivore?
  • What consequences will its destruction have for other components of the agrocenosis?
  • Are there alternative management methods that minimize negative consequences for beneficial organisms?

The economic threshold is a key concept that makes it possible to make decisions on the basis of economic expediency rather than the automatic destruction of all "harmful" organisms (Pedigo, 2002).

Principle 3: An Integrated Approach to the Agrocenosis Is the Basis of Sustainable Farming

The third principle is that sustainable farming requires an integrated approach that takes into account the entire network of interactions in the agrocenosis, not its individual components. This approach is known as agroecology (Gliessman, 2007) or integrated pest management (IPM) (Pedigo, 2002).

What is an integrated approach?

The integrated approach is based on several key principles:

1. Conservation and enhancement of biodiversity. The diversity of plants and animals in the agrocenosis ensures functional redundancy—the ability of the ecosystem to perform its functions even when some species are lost. This increases the resistance of the agrocenosis to stresses (Gliessman, 2007; Shameer & Hardy, 2024).

2. Use of natural processes. Instead of replacing natural processes with external inputs (pesticides, fertilizers), the integrated approach seeks to use natural regulatory mechanisms:

  • Biological control: Conservation and enhancement of natural enemies of pests (Pedigo, 2002).
  • Pollination: Conservation and enhancement of wild pollinators (Garibaldi et al., 2013; IPBES, 2016).
  • Soil fertility: Stimulation of the activity of soil organisms (Weil & Brady, 2017).
  • Nutrient cycling: Use of crop rotations, green manures, and compost (Gliessman, 2007).

3. Adaptive management. The integrated approach recognizes that the agrocenosis is a dynamic system and requires constant monitoring and adaptation of management decisions to changing conditions (Gliessman, 2007).

4. Integration of knowledge. The integrated approach requires the integration of knowledge from different disciplines: ecology, entomology, soil science, plant physiology, and economics (Gliessman, 2007; Ghersa & Martinez-Ghersa, 2019).

Practical examples of the integrated approach

1. Integrated pest management (IPM)

IPM is a pest management system that combines various methods:

  • Monitoring of pest abundance and their natural enemies.
  • Use of economic thresholds for decision-making.
  • Cultural practices (crop rotation, resistant varieties, optimal sowing dates).
  • Biological control (conservation and release of entomophages).
  • Chemical control (only when necessary and with the use of selective pesticides) (Pedigo, 2002).

2. Agroecological systems

Agroecological systems are based on the principles of ecology and seek to imitate natural ecosystems:

  • Polycultures and crop rotations reduce pest abundance and increase biodiversity (Gliessman, 2007).
  • Agroforestry combines trees, crops, and animals, using their interactions to increase productivity and sustainability (Gliessman, 2007).
  • Integrated crop and livestock systems use manure for fertilizer and animals for weed control (Pillay, 2005).

3. Conservation and restoration of habitats

The conservation of natural and seminatural habitats (forest belts, hedgerows, field margins, wetlands) in the agricultural landscape provides shelters and food resources for beneficial organisms (pollinators, entomophages, zoochores). This increases ecosystem services and the sustainability of the agrocenosis (IPBES, 2016; Garibaldi et al., 2013).

Why is this important for the agronomist?

The integrated approach allows the agronomist to:

1. Reduce dependence on external inputs (pesticides, fertilizers), which lowers costs and the ecological footprint.

2. Increase yield and product quality through improved pollination, biological control, and soil fertility.

3. Increase the resistance of the agrocenosis to stresses (drought, floods, pest outbreaks) through diversity and functional redundancy.

4. Ensure long-term productivity and sustainability of farming, preserving natural resources for future generations.

Conclusion

Traditional agriculture is often based on the paradigm of struggle: fighting pests, fighting weeds, fighting diseases. This paradigm regards animals as "enemies" that must be destroyed and ignores their ecological roles.

The agroecological approach offers a paradigm shift: from struggle to management. Instead of destroying "harmful" organisms, the agronomist manages the ecosystem, using natural processes to achieve his goals. This requires a deep understanding of the ecology of "animal—plant" interactions and the ability to apply this knowledge in practice.

Key conclusions:

1. Agrocenosis is an ecosystem in which animals play many roles, influencing plants directly and indirectly.

2. "Animal—plant" interactions are diverse and include phytophagy, pollination, zoochory, mechanical impacts, indirect effects through soil, and vector interactions.

3. The sign of an interaction depends on context; the division into "harmful" and "beneficial" is a simplification.

4. An integrated approach that takes into account the entire network of interactions is the basis of sustainable farming.

5. The agronomist must make decisions on the basis of ecological knowledge, monitoring, and adaptive management, rather than following templates and simplified schemes.

This knowledge forms the basis for understanding the subsequent lectures of the module "Zoology in Agricultural Systems," in which we will examine specific groups of animals, their biology, ecology, and role in agrocenoses in more detail. A holistic understanding of interactions will serve as the foundation for further study of zoology in the context of agriculture.

References

  1. (2014). ‘Biotic Factors’, in Agroecology. : CRC Press, 150-161. doi: 10.1201/b17881-16
  2. (2014). ‘Heterotrophic Organisms’, in Agroecology. : CRC Press, 168-179. doi: 10.1201/b17881-18
  3. (2014). ‘Species Interactions in Crop Communities’, in Agroecology. : CRC Press, 210-221. doi: 10.1201/b17881-21
  4. Albajes, Ramon, Madeira, Filipe (2019). ‘Integrated Pest Management’, in Crop Science. New York, NY: Springer New York, 309-344. doi: 10.1007/978-1-4939-8621-7_164
  5. Bonkowski, Michael, Callaham, M.A. Jr., Clarholm, Marianne, Coleman, D.C., Crossley, D.A. Jr., Griffiths, Bryan, Hendrix, P.F., McSorley, Robert, John, M.G.S., van Vliet, P.C.J. (2012). ‘Soil Fauna’, in Huang, P.Ming, Li, Yuncong, Sumner, M.E. (ed.) Handbook of Soil Sciences Properties and Processes. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, pp. 25-1:25-44.
  6. Czosnek, H., Koren, A., Vidavski, F. (2017). ‘Insect-transmitted viral diseases infecting tomato crops’, in Mattoo, A.K., Handa, A.K. (ed.) Achieving sustainable cultivation of tomatoes. Cambridge, UK: Burleigh Dodds Science Publishing, ch. 13.
  7. DiTomaso, J.M. (2011). ‘Herbicides’, in Simberloff, Daniel, Rejmánek, Marcel (ed.) Encyclopedia of Biological Invasions. Berkeley and Los Angeles, California: University of California Press, pp. 323-331.
  8. Erktan, Amandine, Or, Dani, Scheu, Stefan (2020). ‘The physical structure of soil: Determinant and consequence of trophic interactions’, Soil Biology and Biochemistry, 148(0), 107876. doi: 10.1016/j.soilbio.2020.107876
  9. Garibaldi, L.A., Steffan-Dewenter, Ingolf, Winfree, Rachael, Aizen, M.A., Bommarco, Riccardo, Cunningham, S.A., Kremen, Claire, Carvalheiro, L.G., Harder, L.D., Afik, Ohad, Bartomeus, Ignasi, Benjamin, Faye, Boreux, Virginie, Cariveau, Daniel, Chacoff, N.P., Dudenhöffer, J.H., Freitas, B.M., Ghazoul, Jaboury, Greenleaf, Sarah, Hipólito, Juliana, Holzschuh, Andrea, Howlett, Brad, Isaacs, Rufus, Javorek, S.K., Kennedy, C.M., Krewenka, K.M., Krishnan, Smitha, Mandelik, Yael, Mayfield, M.M., Motzke, Iris, Munyuli, Theodore, Nault, B.A., Otieno, Mark, Petersen, Jessica, Pisanty, Gideon, Potts, S.G., Rader, Romina, Ricketts, T.H., Rundlöf, Maj, Seymour, C.L., Schüepp, Christof, Szentgyörgyi, Hajnalka, Taki, Hisatomo, Tscharntke, Teja, Vergara, C.H., Viana, B.F., Wanger, T.C., Westphal, Catrin, Williams, Neal, Klein, A.M. (2013). ‘Wild Pollinators Enhance Fruit Set of Crops Regardless of Honey Bee Abundance’, Science, 339(6127), 1608-1611. doi: 10.1126/science.1230200 (PubMed)
  10. Ghersa, C.M., Martínez-Ghersa, M.Alejandra (2019). ‘Agroecological Basis for Managing Biotic Constraints’, in Crop Science. New York, NY: Springer New York, 289-308. doi: 10.1007/978-1-4939-8621-7_196
  11. Godó, Laura, Valkó, Orsolya, Borza, S., Deák, B. (2022). ‘A global review on the role of small rodents and lagomorphs (clade Glires) in seed dispersal and plant establishment’, Global Ecology and Conservation, 33(0), e01982. doi: 10.1016/j.gecco.2021.e01982
  12. Goulson, Dave, Nicholls, Elizabeth, Botías, Cristina, Rotheray, E.L. (2015). ‘Bee declines driven by combined stress from parasites, pesticides, and lack of flowers’, Science, 347(6229), null. doi: 10.1126/science.1255957 (PubMed)
  13. Gullan, P.J., Cranston, P.S. (2014). ‘Insects and plants’, in The Insects. An Outline of Entomology. West Sussex, UK: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 289-321.
  14. Hickman, C.R. Jr., Roberts, L.S., Larson, Allan, I’Anson, H. (2004). ‘Animal Ecology’, in Integrated Principles of Zoology. New York, NY: Higher Education, pp. 789-806.
  15. Hogenhout, S.A., Ammar, E., Whitfield, A.E., Redinbaugh, M.G. (2008). ‘Insect Vector Interactions with Persistently Transmitted Viruses’, Annual Review of Phytopathology, 46(1), 327-359. doi: 10.1146/annurev.phyto.022508.092135 (PubMed)
  16. Lengyel, Szabolcs, Gove, A.D., Latimer, A.M., Majer, J.D., Dunn, R.R. (2010). ‘Convergent evolution of seed dispersal by ants, and phylogeny and biogeography in flowering plants: A global survey’, Perspectives in Plant Ecology, Evolution and Systematics, 12(1), 43-55. doi: 10.1016/j.ppees.2009.08.001
  17. Pedigo, L.P. (2002). ‘Economic decision levels for pest populations’, in Entomology and Pest Management. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, pp. 255-288.
  18. Pillay, T.V.R., Kutty, M.N. (2005). ‘Integration of Aquaculture with Crop and Livestock Farming’, in Aquaculture. Principles and Practices. Oxford, UK: Blackwell Publishing, pp. 576-593.
  19. Potts, S.G., Biesmeijer, J.C., Kremen, Claire, Neumann, Peter, Schweiger, Oliver, Kunin, W.E. (2010). ‘Global pollinator declines: trends, impacts and drivers’, Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 25(6), 345-353. doi: 10.1016/j.tree.2010.01.007 (PubMed)
  20. Potts, S.G., Imperatriz-Fonseca, Vera, Ngo, H.T., Biesmeijer, J.C., Breeze, T.D., Dicks, L.V., Garibaldi, L.A., Hill, Rosemary, Settele, Josef, Vanbergen, A.J. (2016). . null Bonn, Germany: IPBES.
  21. Shameer, KS, Hardy, I.CW. (2024). ‘Host–parasitoid trophic webs in complex agricultural systems’, Current Opinion in Insect Science, 65(0), 101253. doi: 10.1016/j.cois.2024.101253 (PubMed)
  22. Sigee, D.C. (1993). ‘Plant pathogenic bacteria in the environment’, in Bacterial Plant Pathology: Cell and Molecular Aspects. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 77-106.
  23. Taiz, Lincoln, Møller, I.Max, Murphy, Angus, Zeiger, Eduardo (2023). ‘Biotic Interactions’, in Plant Physiology and Development. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, pp. 721-781.
  24. Troeh, F.R., Thompson, L.M. (1993). ‘Soil Organic Matter’, in Soil and Soil Fertility. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, pp. 89-110.
  25. Weil, R.R., Brady, N.C. (2017). ‘Nitrogen and Sulfur Economy of Soils’, in The Nature and Properties of Soils. Essex, UK: Pearson Education, pp. 601-660.
  26. Weil, R.R., Brady, N.C. (2017). ‘Organisms and Ecology of the Soil’, in The Nature and Properties of Soils. Essex, UK: Pearson Education, pp. 482-543.
  27. vanStraalen, N.M. (2023). ‘The Selective Environment of the Soil’, in Soil Invertebrates. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 1-35. doi: 10.1201/9780429172830-1