Innate Defense and the Evolution of Adaptive Immunity

Last updated: September 30, 2026

1. Introduction: Immunity as a Defense System

Before we dive into the details of cellular and molecular mechanisms, let us define the subject itself and understand why the immune system is a key factor for the survival of all multicellular organisms.

What is immunity? In the broadest sense, it is the ability of an organism to recognize and protect itself from “non-self”—foreign agents that can cause harm (Hickman et al., 2004). The immune system is not a single organ but a complex, body-wide ensemble of cells, tissues, and molecules working as a unified whole. Its main task is to maintain the integrity and constancy of the organism’s internal environment, or homeostasis.

Why do multicellular organisms need this defense so badly? The reason is that life in any environment—whether soil, water, or air—involves constant contact with a huge number of potential pathogens. Pathogens are organisms that cause disease. They can be divided into several major groups, and each poses a unique threat (Gunn & Pitt, 2022):

1. Viruses. These are noncellular forms of life consisting of a nucleic acid (DNA or RNA) and a protein coat. They cannot reproduce independently and are obligate intracellular parasites. Penetrating a host cell, the virus reprograms its metabolism to produce copies of itself, which often leads to cell death. Examples: African swine fever virus, avian influenza virus (Scanes, 2020).

2. Bacteria. These are unicellular prokaryotic organisms. Many bacteria are harmless or even beneficial, but pathogenic strains can cause serious diseases by releasing toxins or directly damaging tissues. Examples: Vibrio anguillarum in fish, Aeromonas salmonicida in salmonids (Pillay & Kutty, 2005), Clostridium perfringens in birds (Scanes, 2020).

3. Fungi. Pathogenic fungi, or mycoses, often affect the skin, mucous membranes, and internal organs, especially in weakened organisms. Example: Aspergillus fumigatus, which causes aspergillosis in birds (Scanes, 2020).

4. Protozoa. These are unicellular eukaryotes. Many of them are parasites that affect a wide variety of tissues. Example: Eimeria spp., which cause coccidiosis in birds (Scanes, 2020), or Ichthyophthirius multifiliis (“ich”), which affects the skin and gills of fish (Stickney & Gatlin, 2022).

5. Helminths. These are multicellular parasitic worms, including trematodes (flukes), cestodes (tapeworms), and nematodes (roundworms). They can be both external and internal parasites, often reaching enormous sizes and causing significant damage to the host organism. Example: Haemonchus contortus in sheep (Gunn & Pitt, 2022), Ascaridia galli in chickens (Scanes, 2020).

All these organisms constantly attack multicellular animals. Without an effective defense system, no organism could survive and leave offspring. That is why the immune system is the result of long evolution and represents one of the key adaptations that allowed animals to occupy almost all habitats on our planet (Pough et al., 2013). In this lecture, we will trace how this system developed from the simple but effective mechanisms of innate defense in invertebrates to the highly complex, highly specific system of adaptive immunity in vertebrates. We will see that understanding the evolution of immunity is the key to understanding host–parasite interactions, the principles of vaccination, and many practical aspects important for biologists and specialists in agriculture.

In the next section, we will examine in detail the first, most ancient line of defense—innate immunity.

2. Innate Immunity: General Principles

So, we have established that the immune system is necessary for protection against the constant threat from pathogens. Now let us consider the first and most ancient line of defense—innate immunity. It is also called nonspecific immunity, and this name accurately reflects its essence: it responds to pathogens in the same way, without distinguishing their specific types. It is a universal system that we inherited from the very first multicellular organisms (Hickman et al., 2004).

Innate immunity is the evolutionarily most ancient defense system, and it is present in all animals, from sponges to humans. It is based on the ability to recognize common, conserved molecular structures characteristic of entire groups of pathogens but absent from the host’s own cells. Such structures are called pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs), and the receptors that recognize them are called pattern-recognition receptors (PRRs) (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022). This is precisely what allows the system to quickly distinguish “self” from “non-self” and launch a universal response.

Innate immunity can be conventionally divided into several levels of defense: barrier, cellular, and humoral mechanisms.

Barriers: The First Line of Defense

The very first and most important boundary consists of physical and chemical barriers that prevent pathogens from entering the internal environment of the organism. In different groups of animals, these barriers are structured differently, but their general principle is the same (Hickman et al., 2004).

In insects and other arthropods, this role is played by the tough chitinous exoskeleton covering the entire body. It not only protects against mechanical damage but also serves as an impenetrable barrier to most microorganisms. In addition, in insects, the foregut and hindgut are lined with cuticle, and the midgut is protected by the peritrophic membrane—a special envelope that separates food from the epithelium and does not allow microbes through (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

In mollusks and other organisms with soft coverings, such as annelids, the most important barrier is the layer of mucus constantly secreted by the epidermis. Mucus not only mechanically washes away microorganisms but also contains antimicrobial substances such as lysozyme (Gosling, 2015; Straalen, 2023). In vertebrates, the skin is also a powerful barrier, and the mucous membranes of the respiratory and digestive tracts secrete mucus, which performs the same function (Hickman et al., 2004).

Besides physical barriers, there are also chemical ones. For example, the acidic environment in the stomach of vertebrates is destructive to many bacteria and viruses that enter with food (Gunn & Pitt, 2022). Thus, already at the level of coverings and secretions, the organism is able to repel the attack of most potential pathogens.

Cellular Mechanisms: Phagocytosis, Encapsulation, and Melanization

If a pathogen nevertheless manages to overcome the barriers and enter the body, cellular mechanisms of innate immunity come into play. The main one is phagocytosis, that is, the engulfment and digestion of foreign particles by specialized cells (Hickman et al., 2004).

Phagocytosis is an evolutionarily ancient process found in almost all multicellular animals. A phagocytic cell (for example, an amoebocyte, hemocyte, or coelomocyte) recognizes a foreign particle, envelops it with its membrane, and encloses it in a vacuole. Then digestive enzymes from lysosomes enter this vacuole, and the particle is destroyed (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Hickman et al., 2004).

If the foreign object is too large to be engulfed whole (for example, a parasitic worm or an insect larva), another mechanism comes into play—encapsulation. Many phagocytic cells accumulate around the object and form a multilayered capsule around it, isolating it from the rest of the organism. Inside the capsule, unfavorable conditions are created that can lead to the death of the parasite (Gullan & Cranston, 2014; Straalen, 2023).

In arthropods and many other invertebrates, encapsulation is often accompanied by melanization—a process in which melanin is deposited around the capsule. Melanin not only strengthens the capsule but also has toxic properties and participates in the formation of reactive oxygen species that kill the pathogen (Hickman et al., 2004; Straalen, 2023). This process is regulated by a complex enzymatic cascade system known as the prophenoloxidase system.

Humoral Mechanisms: Antimicrobial Peptides, Lysozyme, and the Complement System

Besides cellular reactions, innate immunity also includes humoral factors—that is, molecules dissolved in body fluids that have protective properties. These include antimicrobial peptides, lysozyme, and the complement system.

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are small protein molecules that can kill bacteria, fungi, and some viruses. They have been found in all groups of animals—from insects to mammals (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Hickman et al., 2004). Their mechanism of action is most often associated with disruption of the pathogen’s cell membrane: the peptides embed in the membrane and form pores in it, which leads to cell death. In insects, the best-known AMPs are defensins and cecropins, which are synthesized in the fat body and released into the hemolymph in response to infection (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Lysozyme is an enzyme that destroys the bacterial cell wall, causing their lysis (dissolution). It is contained in saliva, tears, mucus, and other secretions, as well as in phagocytic cells. Lysozyme has been found in a wide variety of animals, including insects, mollusks, and vertebrates (Gosling, 2015; Hickman et al., 2004).

The complement system is a cascade of blood plasma proteins that sequentially activate one another. This cascade can be triggered both by the “classical” pathway (with the participation of antibodies, which we will discuss later) and by the “alternative” pathway, which does not require antibodies and is part of innate immunity. Activation of complement leads to the formation of the membrane attack complex, which punches holes in the membrane of the foreign cell, causing its death. In addition, complement components participate in opsonization—a process that “tags” the pathogen for more efficient phagocytosis (Hickman et al., 2004; Roberts et al., 2013).

Why Is Innate Immunity the Most Ancient Defense System?

Innate immunity is called the most ancient because its mechanisms—phagocytosis, antimicrobial peptides, the complement system—are found in very different, often not closely related, groups of animals. This means that these mechanisms arose very early in the evolution of multicellular organisms and proved so effective that they persisted with virtually no fundamental changes in all modern animals (Hickman et al., 2004; Pough et al., 2013).

Moreover, innate immunity does not depend on prior contact with a pathogen. It works immediately, “by default,” which makes it indispensable for a rapid response to infection. That is why innate immunity is present in all animals—from sponges to humans. It is the foundation upon which the more complex system of adaptive immunity was built in vertebrates.

Thus, innate immunity is a universal, fast, and effective defense system that provides the first and most important line of defense for the organism. It includes barriers, cellular reactions (phagocytosis, encapsulation, melanization), and humoral factors (AMPs, lysozyme, complement). All these mechanisms work in close coordination and provide reliable protection against most pathogens.

In the next section, we will examine in detail how these general principles are implemented in specific groups of invertebrate animals—insects, mollusks, and annelids.

AliExpress WW

3. Innate Immunity in Invertebrates

Now that we have discussed the general principles of innate immunity, let us look at how these universal mechanisms work in specific groups of invertebrate animals. Invertebrates make up the overwhelming majority of animal species on Earth, and they inhabit a wide variety of environments—from soil and fresh waters to the ocean depths. Their immune system, based exclusively on innate mechanisms, demonstrates remarkable diversity and effectiveness (Hickman et al., 2004).

Insect Immunity

Insects are perhaps the most numerous and diverse group of animals, and their immune system has been studied quite well. Like all invertebrates, insects do not have adaptive immunity in the classical sense, but their innate defense works extremely effectively (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

The first barrier is the already mentioned chitinous exoskeleton, which covers the entire body of the insect. However, if a pathogen penetrates through damage to the coverings or through the digestive tract, cellular and humoral mechanisms come into play.

Cellular reactions. Several types of hemocytes circulate in the hemolymph (the insect equivalent of blood) and perform protective functions. The main ones are plasmatocytes and granulocytes. Plasmatocytes are capable of phagocytosis—they engulf and digest bacteria and other small foreign particles. Granulocytes play a key role in encapsulation and melanization (Gullan & Cranston, 2014; Straalen, 2023).

When a pathogen is too large for phagocytosis, for example, a parasitoid larva or a helminth egg, many hemocytes surround it and form a multilayered capsule. This process is accompanied by melanization—the deposition of melanin around the capsule. Melanin not only strengthens the capsule but also has toxic properties and participates in the generation of reactive oxygen species that kill the pathogen (Gullan & Cranston, 2014). This process is regulated by a complex enzymatic cascade system—the prophenoloxidase system—which is triggered upon contact with foreign molecules.

Humoral reactions. In response to infection, the insect fat body begins to synthesize and release antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) into the hemolymph. The best known of these are defensins and cecropins (Gullan & Cranston, 2014). Defensins are active mainly against gram-positive bacteria, while cecropins are active against gram-negative and some gram-positive bacteria. These peptides disrupt the integrity of pathogen cell membranes by forming pores in them.

The synthesis of AMPs is regulated by complex signaling pathways, the main ones being the Toll pathway and the Imd pathway (Gunn & Pitt, 2022). These pathways are activated upon recognition of pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs)—for example, components of bacterial or fungal cell walls. Activation of these pathways leads to the movement of transcription factors into the cell nucleus, where they trigger the expression of genes encoding antimicrobial peptides (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

It is important to note that although insects do not have adaptive immunity, some studies show the presence of “immune memory”—a phenomenon in which repeated infection with the same pathogen causes a faster and stronger response. This phenomenon is called “immune priming” (Gunn & Pitt, 2022), and it resembles, albeit in a simplified form, the adaptive immunity of vertebrates.

Mollusk Immunity

Mollusks are the second-largest group of invertebrates by number of species, and their immune system is also based exclusively on innate mechanisms (Gosling, 2015).

Cellular reactions. The main immune cells of mollusks are hemocytes, circulating in the hemolymph. They can be divided into several types, but the main ones are granulocytes and hyalinocytes. Granulocytes are most active in phagocytosis—they engulf bacteria, fungi, and other small particles. Hyalinocytes are also capable of phagocytosis, but to a lesser extent (Gosling, 2015).

When a mollusk is infected, hemocytes migrate to the site of pathogen penetration and begin actively phagocytosing foreign particles. If the pathogen is too large, for example, a parasitic worm, hemocytes form a capsule around it, isolating it from the rest of the organism. Inside the capsule, unfavorable conditions are created that can lead to the death of the parasite (Gosling, 2015).

Humoral reactions. Various humoral factors are present in mollusk hemolymph, including lectins—proteins capable of binding to carbohydrates on the surface of pathogens. Lectins play the role of opsonins: they “tag” the pathogen for more efficient phagocytosis. In addition, lectins can agglutinate (clump) bacteria, which also promotes their destruction (Gosling, 2015).

Antimicrobial peptides, lysozyme, and components of the complement system have also been found in mollusk hemolymph. For example, AMPs active against a broad spectrum of bacteria and fungi have been identified in oysters and mussels (Gosling, 2015). In addition, antiviral activity of hemolymph has been found in some mollusks, indicating the presence of factors capable of fighting viral infections (Gosling, 2015).

Interestingly, in mollusks, as in insects, “immune memory” has been described—a phenomenon in which repeated infection causes a stronger response. This once again emphasizes that even without adaptive immunity, the innate system can demonstrate elements of specificity and memory (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Annelid Immunity

Annelids, or segmented worms, are another large group of invertebrates living in soil and water. Their immune system is also based on innate mechanisms, and it has been well studied using earthworms as an example (Straalen, 2023).

Cellular reactions. The main immune cells of annelids are coelomocytes—cells circulating in the coelomic fluid. They can be divided into several types: amoebocytes, eleocytes, and granulocytes. Amoebocytes are the main phagocytic cells that engulf bacteria and other foreign particles. They are also capable of encapsulation and the formation of melanin capsules around large parasites (Straalen, 2023).

Eleocytes are cells that detach from chloragogenous tissue (the analogue of the fat body in insects) and enter the coelomic fluid. They contain granules with metals and other substances and can participate in detoxification and defense against pathogens. Granulocytes also participate in protective reactions, releasing various biologically active molecules (Straalen, 2023).

Humoral reactions. Various humoral factors are present in the coelomic fluid of annelids, including lysozyme, agglutinins (lectins), and antimicrobial peptides. For example, AMPs active against bacteria and fungi have been identified in earthworms (Straalen, 2023). In addition, components of the complement system have been found in the coelomic fluid, participating in opsonization and lysis of pathogens.

Of particular interest is chloragogenous tissue—the tissue surrounding the intestine of the earthworm. It performs many functions, including detoxification, nutrient storage, and participation in immune reactions. Chloragogenous tissue contains cells that can phagocytose foreign particles and synthesize antimicrobial peptides (Straalen, 2023).

Why Do Invertebrates Lack Adaptive Immunity in the Classical Sense?

Adaptive immunity, as we will see later, is based on lymphocytes (B and T cells) and antibodies, which provide high specificity and memory. Invertebrates have neither lymphocytes nor antibodies in the form found in vertebrates. Their immune system is not capable of recognizing specific antigens with the same precision as the adaptive system, and it does not form long-term memory of a specific pathogen (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

However, as we have already mentioned, invertebrates still have some elements of “memory”—immune priming. This phenomenon consists in the fact that after the first contact with a pathogen, the organism responds to repeated infection faster and more strongly. However, this response is not strictly specific and does not last as long as in vertebrates (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Why Is Invertebrate Innate Immunity Effective?

Despite the absence of adaptive immunity, the innate system of invertebrates is extremely effective. This is explained by several reasons:

1. Speed of response. Innate immunity works immediately, without the time needed for recognition and proliferation of lymphocyte clones. This is especially important for organisms with short life cycles, such as many insects.

2. Broad spectrum of action. Antimicrobial peptides and other humoral factors are effective against a wide range of pathogens—bacteria, fungi, protozoa, and even some viruses. This allows the organism to fight most infections without the need to produce specific antibodies.

3. Economy. Innate immunity does not require large energy expenditures for maintaining lymphocyte clones and synthesizing antibodies. For invertebrates, which often live under conditions of limited resources, this is an important advantage.

4. Coordination with other systems. The immune system of invertebrates is closely connected with other physiological systems, such as the nervous and endocrine systems. This allows the organism to respond quickly to stress and infection, mobilizing all available resources (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Thus, the innate immunity of invertebrates is a highly effective, fast, and economical defense system that allows these animals to exist successfully in a wide variety of environments. It includes cellular reactions (phagocytosis, encapsulation, melanization) and humoral factors (AMPs, lysozyme, lectins, complement). Despite the absence of adaptive immunity in the classical sense, invertebrates possess elements of “immune memory,” which makes their defense system even more sophisticated.

In the next section, we will move on to consider adaptive immunity—the evolutionarily younger and more complex system that is characteristic only of vertebrate animals.

4. Adaptive Immunity: General Principles

We have examined innate immunity in detail—an ancient, fast, and universal defense system present in all animals. Now it is time to become acquainted with the second, evolutionarily younger line of defense—adaptive immunity. It is also called acquired or specific immunity, and these names accurately reflect its essence: it forms during the lifetime of the organism and has high specificity for a particular pathogen (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

What Is Adaptive Immunity?

Adaptive immunity is a defense system that turns on after the first contact with a pathogen and provides a faster and stronger response upon repeated encounter with the same causative agent. Unlike innate immunity, which responds to pathogens in the same way without distinguishing them, adaptive immunity “remembers” a specific enemy and forms long-term protection against it (Hickman et al., 2004).

The main difference between adaptive and innate immunity lies in three key features: specificity, memory, and tolerance to “self.”

Specificity. The adaptive immune system is capable of recognizing specific antigens—molecular structures characteristic of a given pathogen. An antigen can be a protein, polysaccharide, lipid, or nucleic acid. Each antigen has unique regions called epitopes, which are recognized by lymphocyte receptors. Specificity means that antibodies and T-cell receptors formed against one pathogen will not be effective against another (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Memory. After the first contact with a pathogen, some lymphocytes become memory cells, which persist in the organism for a long time—sometimes for life. Upon repeated encounter with the same pathogen, these cells are rapidly activated and launch a powerful and fast immune response. This mechanism underlies vaccination (Hickman et al., 2004).

Tolerance to “self.” The adaptive immune system must be able to distinguish “self” from “non-self.” During development, lymphocytes that recognize the organism’s own molecules are destroyed or inactivated. This prevents autoimmune reactions—attacks by the immune system on its own tissues (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Cells of Adaptive Immunity: Lymphocytes

The main cells of adaptive immunity are lymphocytes—a special type of white blood cell. In jawed vertebrates, there are two main types of lymphocytes: B lymphocytes and T lymphocytes (Hickman et al., 2004; Pough et al., 2013).

B lymphocytes (B cells) mature in the bone marrow (from Latin bursa—a pouch; in birds they mature in the bursa of Fabricius). They carry antibodies on their surface—immunoglobulin receptors. When an antigen binds to such a receptor, the B cell is activated, begins to divide, and turns into plasma cells, which secrete antibodies into the blood and lymph. This is the basis of humoral immunity (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

T lymphocytes (T cells) mature in the thymus. They carry T-cell receptors on their surface, which recognize antigens presented on the surface of other cells in complex with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. T cells perform several functions: some help B cells become activated (T helpers), others destroy infected cells (cytotoxic T cells), and still others regulate the strength of the immune response (regulatory T cells) (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Antibodies (Immunoglobulins)

Antibodies, or immunoglobulins (Ig), are proteins synthesized by B lymphocytes and their descendants—plasma cells. An antibody is a Y-shaped molecule consisting of two heavy and two light polypeptide chains connected by disulfide bonds (Hickman et al., 2004; Roberts et al., 2013).

Each antibody has two sites that bind to antigen—Fab fragments (antigen-binding fragments)—and one site that interacts with other components of the immune system—the Fc fragment (crystallizable fragment). The variable regions of the Fab fragments determine the specificity of the antibody: they form a unique “pocket” that is complementary to a specific epitope of the antigen (Hickman et al., 2004).

In mammals, there are five main classes of immunoglobulins: IgM, IgG, IgA, IgD, and IgE. Each class performs its own functions. For example, IgM is the first immunoglobulin synthesized during the primary immune response; IgG is the main class of antibodies in the blood, providing long-term protection; IgA is a secretory immunoglobulin that protects mucous membranes; IgE participates in allergic reactions and defense against parasites (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Hickman et al., 2004).

Why Is Adaptive Immunity More Effective but Slower?

Adaptive immunity has a number of advantages over innate immunity. It provides high specificity, which allows precise targeting of a particular pathogen. It forms immune memory, which makes it possible to respond quickly and effectively to repeated infection. It is capable of recognizing and destroying pathogens that “disguise” themselves as the organism’s own cells (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

However, adaptive immunity also has its drawbacks. First of all, it requires time to develop. Upon first contact with a pathogen, it takes several days for lymphocytes to activate, multiply, and begin synthesizing antibodies. During this time, the organism relies on innate immunity, which contains the infection. This is why many infectious diseases have an incubation period—the time from pathogen entry to the appearance of symptoms (Hickman et al., 2004).

In addition, adaptive immunity is energetically expensive. Maintaining the diversity of lymphocytes and synthesizing antibodies require significant resources. This is one reason why adaptive immunity exists only in vertebrates—animals with a higher metabolic rate and complex organization (Pough et al., 2013).

Why Is Adaptive Immunity Present Only in Jawed Vertebrates?

Adaptive immunity in the classical sense—with B and T lymphocytes, antibodies, and V(D)J recombination—is characteristic only of jawed vertebrates (Gnathostomata). This includes all fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals. Jawless vertebrates—lampreys and hagfish—have an alternative adaptive immune system based on VLR receptors, which we will consider in the next section (Pough et al., 2013; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Why did adaptive immunity arise specifically in jawed vertebrates? One reason is that jawed vertebrates are active predators with a high metabolic rate and complex behavior. They are constantly exposed to a variety of pathogens and need a more sophisticated defense system. In addition, the appearance of jaws and the associated changes in lifestyle and feeding led to an increase in the diversity of pathogens these animals encountered (Pough et al., 2013).

Thus, adaptive immunity is an evolutionarily young system that arose in jawed vertebrates and provides highly specific, long-term protection against pathogens. It is based on lymphocytes (B and T cells), antibodies, and mechanisms for generating receptor diversity. Although adaptive immunity requires time to develop, it is a powerful tool for fighting infections and underlies vaccination.

In the next section, we will examine in detail the evolution of adaptive immunity and the key molecular mechanisms that made it possible—V(D)J recombination and RAG genes.

5. Evolution of Adaptive Immunity

We have considered the general principles of adaptive immunity and have seen that it is a highly specific, memory-bearing system characteristic only of jawed vertebrates. Now let us ask: how and when did this system arise? What molecular mechanisms made its appearance possible? And why is this evolutionary acquisition considered one of the key events in the history of vertebrate animals?

The Emergence of Adaptive Immunity in Jawed Vertebrates

Adaptive immunity in the form we know it—with B and T lymphocytes, antibodies, and T-cell receptors—appears in jawed vertebrates (Gnathostomata). This event occurred approximately 500 million years ago, in the early Paleozoic, when the first jawed fishes began to explore new ecological niches (Pough et al., 2013).

Before the appearance of jawed vertebrates, their ancestors—jawless fishes such as ostracoderms—relied exclusively on innate immunity. However, with the appearance of jaws and the transition to active predation, these organisms encountered new challenges. An active lifestyle, diverse diet, and increase in body size led to pathogens becoming more diverse and numerous. Innate immunity was insufficient for effective combat against them (Pough et al., 2013; Hickman et al., 2004).

It was during this period in vertebrate evolution that a fundamentally new defense mechanism appeared—adaptive immunity. Its key difference from innate immunity lies in the ability to generate a virtually unlimited diversity of receptors that can recognize any antigens, including those the organism has never encountered before.

V(D)J Recombination: The Mechanism for Generating Diversity

Adaptive immunity is based on a unique genetic mechanism called V(D)J recombination (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Hickman et al., 2004). This process allows millions, and possibly billions, of different variants of antibodies and T-cell receptors to be created from a limited number of genes.

Let us break down how this works. The genes encoding the heavy and light chains of antibodies, as well as T-cell receptors, consist of several segments: V (variable), D (diversity), and J (joining). During lymphocyte maturation, these segments are randomly rearranged, joining with one another in various combinations. For example, one V segment can join with one D segment and one J segment, forming a unique sequence that will encode a unique antigen-binding site (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

This process resembles assembling a construction kit: you have a limited set of parts, but by combining them in different ways, you can create an enormous number of different constructions. It is V(D)J recombination that provides the fantastic diversity of antibodies and T-cell receptors that allows the immune system to recognize virtually any pathogen.

RAG Genes: Origin and Function

The key “tools” for V(D)J recombination are the RAG genes (Recombination Activating Genes)—RAG1 and RAG2 (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013). These genes encode enzymes that cut DNA at specific sites—precisely where the V, D, and J segments are located—and then join them in new combinations.

RAG genes are a unique acquisition of jawed vertebrates. Interestingly, according to current views, they originated from transposons—“jumping genes” capable of moving through the genome. Approximately 500 million years ago, a transposon that entered the genome of the ancestor of jawed vertebrates was “domesticated” and turned into RAG1 and RAG2. This event is considered one of the key moments in the evolution of adaptive immunity (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

The function of RAG proteins is that they recognize special signal sequences flanking the V, D, and J segments, cut the DNA at these sites, and join the segments in a new combination. As a result, a unique gene is formed that will encode a unique receptor. This process occurs independently in each lymphocyte, which ensures enormous diversity (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Why Did Adaptive Immunity Allow Vertebrates to Effectively Fight Pathogens?

The emergence of adaptive immunity gave jawed vertebrates an enormous advantage in the fight against pathogens. Here are the main reasons:

1. Unlimited diversity of receptors. V(D)J recombination makes it possible to create millions of different antibodies and T-cell receptors. This means that the immune system can recognize virtually any pathogen, even one the organism has never encountered before. Innate immunity, by contrast, recognizes only a limited set of conserved molecular structures (PAMPs) (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

2. Specificity. Adaptive immunity provides high specificity of response. Antibodies and T cells target specific epitopes of the pathogen, which allows precise destruction of it without damaging the organism’s own tissues.

3. Immune memory. After the first contact with a pathogen, some lymphocytes become memory cells. Upon repeated encounter with the same pathogen, they are rapidly activated and launch a powerful and fast response. This is the basis of vaccination and long-term protection against infections (Hickman et al., 2004).

4. Fighting intracellular pathogens. Adaptive immunity includes not only the humoral response (antibodies) but also the cellular response (T lymphocytes). Cytotoxic T cells are capable of recognizing and destroying cells infected with viruses or intracellular bacteria. Innate immunity does not always cope with such pathogens (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

5. Tolerance to “self.” The adaptive immune system is capable of distinguishing “self” from “non-self” with high accuracy. This prevents autoimmune reactions and allows the organism to effectively fight pathogens without damaging its own tissues (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Why Is This Evolutionary Acquisition Comparable in Significance to Other Key Innovations?

The emergence of adaptive immunity is often compared in significance to such key evolutionary innovations as the appearance of jaws, limbs, or warm-bloodedness. Why?

The reason is that adaptive immunity allowed vertebrate animals to explore new ecological niches and increase lifespan. It provided effective protection against diverse pathogens, which became especially important for long-lived organisms with slow reproduction. In addition, adaptive immunity created the basis for the formation of complex social interactions, as it allowed organisms to survive under conditions of high population density, where the risk of infection spread is especially high (Pough et al., 2013; Hickman et al., 2004).

Moreover, adaptive immunity became a prerequisite for the emergence of vaccination—one of the greatest achievements of medicine and veterinary science. Without understanding the mechanisms of adaptive immunity, it would have been impossible to develop vaccines that have saved millions of lives (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Thus, the evolution of adaptive immunity is a key event in the history of vertebrate animals. It became possible thanks to the emergence of V(D)J recombination and RAG genes, which provided the generation of unlimited receptor diversity. Adaptive immunity gave vertebrates a powerful tool for fighting pathogens, which allowed them to occupy a dominant position in most ecosystems on Earth.

In the next section, we will consider an alternative solution to the problem of adaptive immunity—the system that arose in jawless vertebrates, lampreys, and hagfish.

6. Alternative Solutions: Immunity of Jawless Vertebrates

We have seen that the adaptive immunity of jawed vertebrates is based on V(D)J recombination and RAG genes, which provide a virtually unlimited diversity of antibodies and T-cell receptors. However, a question arises: what about jawless vertebrates—lampreys and hagfish? After all, they are also vertebrates, but they diverged from the common trunk long before the appearance of jaws and RAG genes. It turns out that they also have adaptive immunity, but it is structured completely differently (Pough et al., 2013; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Lampreys and Hagfish: VLR Receptors

Lampreys and hagfish are the only modern representatives of jawless vertebrates. They belong to the infraphylum Agnatha and occupy a unique position in the evolutionary tree of vertebrates. Like all vertebrates, they possess complex organization, but their immune system long remained a mystery to researchers (Pough et al., 2013).

For a long time it was believed that jawless vertebrates lack adaptive immunity, since they have neither a thymus nor lymphocytes in the classical sense, nor antibodies, nor RAG genes (Hickman et al., 2004). However, in the early 21st century, scientists made an amazing discovery: lampreys and hagfish were found to have a completely different adaptive immune system based on VLR receptors (Variable Lymphocyte Receptors) (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

VLR receptors are proteins synthesized by lymphocyte-like cells of jawless vertebrates. They are capable of recognizing antigens with high specificity, similar to the antibodies of jawed vertebrates. However, their structure and mechanism for generating diversity are fundamentally different from those of jawed vertebrates (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

How Does the VLR System Work?

Unlike V(D)J recombination, which “shuffles” ready-made gene segments, the VLR system uses a different mechanism. VLR genes consist of a large number of short leucine-rich repeats (LRRs). During lymphocyte maturation, these repeats are randomly inserted into the VLR gene with the help of an enzyme called cytidine deaminase (Gunn & Pitt, 2022). This process resembles text editing: instead of rearranging ready-made paragraphs, you insert or replace individual letters and words, thereby creating new text.

As a result of such “editing,” each lymphocyte of a jawless vertebrate receives a unique VLR receptor that can recognize a specific antigen. After activation, the lymphocyte begins to multiply and secrete soluble forms of VLR, which circulate in the blood and bind pathogens—similar to how the antibodies of jawed vertebrates do this (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Why Do Jawless Vertebrates Have Adaptive Immunity but Organized Differently?

The fact that jawless vertebrates have adaptive immunity but based on VLR receptors rather than antibodies is a striking example of convergent evolution—a process in which different groups of organisms independently acquire similar traits to solve the same problem (Pough et al., 2013).

From an evolutionary point of view, this means that the ability for adaptive immunity—that is, for specific recognition of pathogens and formation of immune memory—arose in vertebrate evolution twice, but by different paths. In jawed vertebrates, this occurred through the “domestication” of a transposon, which gave rise to RAG genes and V(D)J recombination. In jawless vertebrates, it occurred through a completely different mechanism based on somatic recombination of LRRs (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

This discovery is important for understanding the evolution of immunity. It shows that adaptive immunity is not the only possible path to highly specific defense. Nature found two different solutions to the same problem, and both proved effective.

Why Is This an Example of “Different Solutions to One Problem”?

Let us compare the two systems:

FeatureJawed vertebrates (V(D)J system)Jawless vertebrates (VLR system)
Main receptorsAntibodies and T-cell receptorsVLR receptors
Mechanism for generating diversityV(D)J recombination involving RAG genesSomatic recombination of LRRs
Origin“Domesticated” transposonsNot associated with transposons
CellsB and T lymphocytesLymphocyte-like cells
OrgansThymus, bone marrow, spleen, lymph nodesAbsent (lymphoid tissue diffuse)
MemoryPresentPresent

As can be seen from the table, both systems solve the same problem—they provide specific recognition of pathogens and formation of immune memory—but use different molecular tools and different anatomical structures for this. This is a brilliant example of how evolution can lead to the same functional result by different paths (Pough et al., 2013; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Why Is the Study of Jawless Vertebrate Immunity Important for Understanding the Evolution of Immunity?

The study of the immune system of lampreys and hagfish is of enormous importance for understanding the evolution of immunity for several reasons:

1. Understanding the origin of adaptive immunity. By studying the VLR system, we can better understand what principles underlie adaptive immunity in general. This helps reconstruct the evolutionary path that led to the appearance of highly specific defense in vertebrates.

2. Alternative defense strategies. The VLR system may suggest new approaches to creating therapeutic agents. For example, VLR receptors possess high stability and specificity, making them promising candidates for the development of new diagnostic and therapeutic drugs (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

3. Evolutionary biology. Studying jawless vertebrates helps understand how key vertebrate innovations evolved. Lampreys and hagfish occupy a unique position in the evolutionary tree, and studying them allows us to “look back” into the past and understand what the first vertebrates were like.

4. Comparative immunology. Comparing the VLR system and the V(D)J system helps identify general principles of adaptive immunity that do not depend on specific molecular mechanisms. This deepens our understanding of what adaptive immunity is in essence.

Thus, jawless vertebrates—lampreys and hagfish—represent a unique example of an alternative solution to the problem of adaptive immunity. Their VLR system, based on somatic recombination of LRRs, demonstrates that nature is capable of creating highly specific defense systems using different molecular tools. Studying this system not only expands our knowledge of the evolution of immunity but also opens new prospects for practical application in medicine and veterinary science.

In the next section, we will return to jawed vertebrates and examine in detail how cellular and humoral immunity interact, providing effective protection for the organism.

7. The Immune Response: Cellular and Humoral

We have become acquainted with adaptive immunity, its evolution, and the molecular mechanisms underlying it. Now let us break down exactly how the adaptive immune response works. In jawed vertebrates, it is divided into two closely interacting branches: humoral immunity and cellular immunity (Hickman et al., 2004). The names reflect the nature of the factors that provide protection: in the first case, these are soluble molecules (antibodies) in the blood and lymph (humoral factors); in the second, the cells themselves (T lymphocytes), which directly contact other cells of the organism.

Humoral Immunity: B Lymphocytes and Antibodies

Humoral immunity is protection mediated by antibodies, which are synthesized by B lymphocytes and their descendants—plasma cells. B lymphocytes mature in the bone marrow (in birds, in the bursa of Fabricius), which is where their name comes from (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

On the surface of each B lymphocyte there is a unique antigen-recognizing receptor—a membrane-bound form of antibody (immunoglobulin). When this receptor binds to the corresponding antigen (for example, a protein on the surface of a bacterium or virus), the B cell is activated. For full activation, a B cell usually requires help from T helpers, which we will discuss below (Roberts et al., 2013).

After activation, the B lymphocyte begins to intensively divide, forming a clone of identical cells. Most of them turn into plasma cells—“factories” for antibody production. Plasma cells secrete enormous amounts of antibodies into the blood and lymph. Another part of the clone turns into B memory cells, which persist in the organism for a long time and provide a rapid response upon repeated encounter with the same pathogen (Hickman et al., 2004).

Antibodies are Y-shaped proteins, or immunoglobulins. In mammals, there are five classes: IgM, IgG, IgA, IgD, and IgE. Each class performs its own functions. For example, IgM is the first immunoglobulin synthesized during the primary response; IgG is the main class in the blood, providing long-term protection; IgA is a secretory immunoglobulin that protects mucous membranes; IgE participates in allergic reactions and defense against parasites (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Antibodies themselves do not kill pathogens. They “tag” them for destruction by other components of the immune system. The main functions of antibodies:

  • Neutralization. Antibodies bind to toxins or viral particles and block their ability to interact with host cells.
  • Opsonization. By coating the surface of a pathogen, antibodies make it more “visible” to phagocytes (macrophages and neutrophils), which recognize the Fc fragment of the antibody and engulf the pathogen.
  • Complement activation. Binding of antibodies to antigen triggers the classical pathway of the complement system, leading to lysis (destruction) of the pathogen.
  • Antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC). Antibodies bound to an infected cell are recognized by natural killers (NK cells) and other effector cells, which destroy that cell (Hickman et al., 2004; Roberts et al., 2013).

Cellular Immunity: T Lymphocytes

Cellular immunity is protection mediated by T lymphocytes. These cells mature in the thymus, which is where their name comes from. T lymphocytes do not secrete antibodies; instead, they recognize antigens presented on the surface of other cells in complex with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

There are two main classes of MHC molecules:

  • MHC I is present on the surface of almost all nucleated cells. They present fragments of intracellular proteins (including viral ones) to cytotoxic T lymphocytes.
  • MHC II is present only on specialized antigen-presenting cells (macrophages, dendritic cells, B lymphocytes). They present fragments of externally engulfed pathogens to T helpers (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

T lymphocytes are divided into several functional types:

1. T helpers (CD4+ T cells). These are the “conductors” of the immune response. They recognize antigens in complex with MHC II. After activation, T helpers secrete cytokines—signaling molecules that stimulate the proliferation and differentiation of other immune cells: B lymphocytes (for antibody production), cytotoxic T cells, and macrophages (Hickman et al., 2004). Depending on the profile of secreted cytokines, T helpers are divided into subtypes: Th1 (activate cellular immunity), Th2 (activate humoral immunity, especially against parasites), Th17 (participate in inflammation and mucosal defense), and Treg (regulatory T cells, suppressing excessive reactions) (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013).

2. Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs, CD8+ T cells). These cells recognize antigens in complex with MHC I. Their main task is to destroy infected cells, as well as tumor cells. CTLs attach to the target cell and release the proteins perforin and granzyme B. Perforin forms pores in the target membrane, and granzyme B penetrates inside and triggers apoptosis (programmed cell death). Thus, CTLs destroy the “factories” producing viruses or intracellular bacteria (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

3. Regulatory T cells (Tregs). These cells (CD4+CD25+FoxP3+) suppress the activity of other immune cells, preventing excessive reactions and autoimmune diseases. They play a key role in maintaining tolerance to “self” and in limiting inflammation (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Interaction of Cellular and Humoral Immunity

Humoral and cellular immunity are not two independent systems but two branches of a single adaptive immune response that interact closely. T helpers play a central role in this interaction (Hickman et al., 2004; Roberts et al., 2013).

When a pathogen enters the organism, antigen-presenting cells (for example, dendritic cells or macrophages) engulf it, break it down into fragments, and present them on their surface in complex with MHC II. T helpers, having recognized this complex, are activated and begin to secrete cytokines. These cytokines, in turn, activate:

  • B lymphocytes, which after this turn into plasma cells and begin to synthesize antibodies (humoral response).
  • Cytotoxic T lymphocytes, which begin to destroy infected cells (cellular response).
  • Macrophages, increasing their phagocytic activity.

Thus, T helpers act as a “command center,” coordinating both branches of adaptive immunity for the most effective destruction of the pathogen.

Why Are Both Types Necessary for Effective Defense?

The division into humoral and cellular immunity is not accidental. Different pathogens require different strategies of combat. Antibodies are effective against extracellular pathogens—bacteria, viruses located in the blood or lymph, as well as against toxins. Antibodies bind them, neutralize them, and tag them for destruction by phagocytes. However, antibodies cannot penetrate inside a cell, so they are useless against pathogens that are already inside cells (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

This is where T lymphocytes come onto the scene. Cytotoxic T cells recognize infected cells by fragments of viral or bacterial proteins on their surface (in complex with MHC I) and destroy them, depriving the pathogen of its “refuge.” Thus, cellular immunity fights intracellular pathogens—viruses, some bacteria (for example, Listeria, Mycobacterium), as well as tumor cells (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Pough et al., 2013).

In addition, cellular immunity plays an important role in transplant rejection and in defense against parasites, especially helminths, which are too large for phagocytosis. In this case, type 2 T helpers (Th2) activate eosinophils and other cells that attack the parasite (Roberts et al., 2013).

Thus, humoral and cellular immunity complement each other. Antibodies act in the extracellular space, while T cells act at the cellular level. Only the joint work of both branches provides full protection of the organism from the entire diversity of pathogens.

In the next section, we will examine how immune memory is formed and how vaccination works on its basis—one of the greatest achievements of medicine and veterinary science.

8. Immune Memory and Vaccination

We have discussed how cellular and humoral immunity interact, providing effective protection for the organism. Now let us focus on one of the most amazing properties of the adaptive immune system—immune memory. It is this property that underlies vaccination, which has become one of the greatest achievements of medicine and veterinary science, saving millions of lives (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

What Is Immune Memory?

Immune memory is the ability of the adaptive immune system to “remember” a pathogen the organism has already encountered and to provide a faster and stronger response upon repeated encounter with it. This phenomenon is based on the formation of long-lived memory cells—B and T lymphocytes that persist in the organism after the primary immune response (Hickman et al., 2004).

When a B lymphocyte is activated by antigen, part of its clone turns into plasma cells that synthesize antibodies, and another part turns into B memory cells. These cells do not constantly secrete antibodies, but they are “ready” for immediate action. They circulate in the blood and lymph, linger in lymph nodes and the spleen, and can persist in the organism for years, and sometimes for life (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013).

Similarly, after activation of T lymphocytes, part of their clone turns into T memory cells, which persist in the organism and provide a rapid response upon repeated contact with the same antigen.

Primary and Secondary Immune Response

To understand how immune memory works, let us compare two types of response: primary and secondary (Hickman et al., 2004).

The primary immune response develops upon the organism’s first contact with a pathogen. During this time, innate immunity contains the infection while the adaptive system “tunes up.” It takes several days for B and T lymphocytes specific to the given antigen to activate, multiply, and begin synthesizing antibodies. IgM antibodies appear first in the blood, then IgG. The concentration of antibodies increases gradually, peaks after 1–2 weeks, and then decreases. This period is accompanied by symptoms of disease, since the pathogen manages to multiply and harm the organism (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

The secondary immune response develops upon repeated encounter with the same pathogen. Thanks to the presence of memory cells, it starts faster and proceeds more intensively. Activated B memory cells quickly turn into plasma cells and begin to synthesize antibodies—mainly IgG, which have higher affinity (ability to bind antigen) and greater effectiveness. The concentration of antibodies rises rapidly, reaches a higher peak, and persists longer. The pathogen is destroyed so quickly that symptoms of disease often do not have time to manifest (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

The difference between primary and secondary responses is clearly illustrated by a graph of antibody titer versus time. In the primary response, there is a slow rise; in the secondary response, a steep and high peak. This is the manifestation of immune memory.

Why Is the Secondary Response Faster and Stronger?

There are several reasons:

1. Greater number of memory cells. After the primary response, the organism retains significantly more B and T cells specific to the given antigen than naive lymphocytes that existed before first contact.

2. Faster activation. Memory cells are in “combat readiness”—they express receptors that allow them to respond to antigen faster. In addition, they migrate to lymphoid organs, where the probability of encountering antigen is higher.

3. Antibody class switching. In the secondary response, B memory cells synthesize mainly IgG, IgA, or IgE rather than IgM. These antibody classes possess higher affinity and better effector functions.

4. Affinity maturation. During the primary response, B cells undergo somatic hypermutation and selection, resulting in clones with higher affinity for the antigen. These high-affinity clones are preserved as memory cells and provide a more effective secondary response (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013).

Vaccination: Principle, Types of Vaccines

Immune memory is a natural defense mechanism, but it has a significant drawback: to form memory, one must suffer through infection, which can lead to severe complications or death. Vaccination allows this problem to be bypassed: it “teaches” the immune system without causing disease (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Hickman et al., 2004).

The principle of vaccination consists in introducing a vaccine into the organism—a preparation containing an attenuated, killed, or fragmented pathogen (or its antigens) that is incapable of causing disease but stimulates the adaptive immune response. As a result, memory cells are formed, which upon encounter with the real pathogen provide a fast and effective secondary response. Thus, vaccination creates an artificial “primary response” not accompanied by clinical symptoms (Roberts et al., 2013).

There are several types of vaccines:

1. Live attenuated vaccines. Contain weakened (attenuated) strains of the pathogen that have lost the ability to cause disease but retained immunogenicity. Examples: vaccines against measles, rubella, mumps, as well as veterinary vaccines against Newcastle disease in birds and infectious bronchitis (Scanes, 2020). Live vaccines usually induce long-lasting immunity but require caution in immunodeficient patients.

2. Inactivated (killed) vaccines. Contain killed pathogens that cannot reproduce but retain antigenic properties. Examples: vaccines against rabies, influenza, as well as veterinary vaccines against vibriosis in fish (Pillay & Kutty, 2005). Such vaccines are safe but often require adjuvants (substances that enhance the immune response) and multiple administrations.

3. Subunit (molecular) vaccines. Contain only purified antigens of the pathogen—for example, proteins or polysaccharides. Examples: vaccine against hepatitis B, as well as vaccines against coccidiosis in birds (Scanes, 2020). These vaccines are the safest but often less immunogenic and require adjuvants.

4. Toxoids. Contain inactivated toxins that have lost toxicity but retained immunogenicity. Examples: vaccines against tetanus and diphtheria. In veterinary medicine, they are used to prevent clostridioses in animals.

5. mRNA vaccines. This is a relatively new type of vaccine that contains messenger RNA (mRNA) encoding an antigen. Once inside cells, the mRNA “instructs” them to synthesize a viral protein, which is recognized by the immune system. Examples: vaccines against COVID-19. In veterinary medicine, mRNA vaccines for animals are being developed.

Why Is Vaccination One of the Greatest Achievements of Medicine and Veterinary Science?

Vaccination is a powerful tool for preventing infectious diseases. It has made it possible to eliminate smallpox, nearly defeat polio and measles in many regions of the world, and significantly reduce morbidity and mortality from many other infections (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

In veterinary medicine, vaccination is no less important. It protects agricultural animals from deadly diseases such as anthrax, foot-and-mouth disease, classical swine fever, Newcastle disease, and many others. Vaccination not only saves animal lives but also prevents economic losses associated with livestock death, reduced productivity, and trade restrictions (Scanes, 2020; Pillay & Kutty, 2005).

In addition, vaccination reduces the need for antibiotics, which is important for combating antibiotic resistance. Vaccines do not leave residues in products and do not cause resistance in pathogens, unlike chemotherapeutic agents (Pillay & Kutty, 2005).

Thus, immune memory is a key property of the adaptive immune system that provides faster and more effective protection upon repeated encounter with a pathogen. Vaccination exploits this mechanism, “teaching” the immune system without the risk of disease. Vaccination has become one of the greatest achievements of medicine and veterinary science, and its importance for human and animal health is difficult to overestimate.

In the next section, we will examine why parasites pose a special problem for the immune system and what adaptations allow them to evade the immune response.

9. Immunity and Parasites

We have examined how adaptive immunity works, how immune memory is formed, and how vaccination allows these mechanisms to be used to protect against infections. However, there is a special group of pathogens that poses the most complex challenge to the immune system—parasites. Unlike viruses and bacteria, parasites are multicellular organisms (helminths) or complex unicellular eukaryotes (protozoa) that have undergone a long path of coevolution with their hosts. That is why they possess remarkable adaptations that allow them to evade the immune response and cause chronic diseases (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013).

Why Are Parasites a Special Problem for the Immune System?

Parasites differ from other pathogens in a number of key features that make them especially difficult targets for the immune system (Roberts et al., 2013; Gunn & Pitt, 2022):

1. Large size. Helminths (trematodes, cestodes, nematodes) can reach centimeters, and sometimes meters, in length. They are too large to be engulfed by phagocytes. Encapsulation, which is effective against small pathogens, also does not always work, since the parasite may be too large and motile.

2. Complex life cycles. Many parasites pass through several developmental stages, often with changes of hosts. Each stage may have its own antigens, which confuses the immune system. For example, a larva and an adult worm may be antigenically different, and the immune response formed against one stage does not protect against another (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

3. Intracellular and extracellular existence. Some protozoa (for example, Plasmodium, Leishmania, Toxoplasma) live inside host cells, where antibodies cannot reach them. Others (for example, adult helminths) are extracellular but protected by a dense cuticle or tegument. This requires the immune system to use different strategies.

4. Long coevolution. Parasites and their hosts evolved together for millions of years. Parasites “learned” to manipulate the host immune system, suppress it, or deceive it. As a result, many parasitic infections become chronic and can last for years, and sometimes for life (Roberts et al., 2013).

Parasite Adaptations to the Immune Response

Parasites have developed many mechanisms allowing them to evade the immune response. Let us consider the main ones (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013).

1. Antigenic variation

This is perhaps the best-known mechanism. The parasite constantly changes its surface antigens, so the immune system does not have time to develop an effective response. A classic example is Trypanosoma brucei, the causative agent of African sleeping sickness. This parasite is covered with a dense layer of variant surface glycoproteins (VSGs). The genome of the trypanosome contains more than 1,000 VSG genes, but only one is expressed. When the immune system produces antibodies against this VSG, the parasite switches to another gene, and the antibodies become useless. This leads to a wave-like course of the disease: periods of exacerbation alternate with remissions, but the parasite does not disappear completely (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013).

Another example is Giardia duodenalis, which changes surface proteins (VSPs) to avoid the action of antibodies (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

2. Immunosuppression

Many parasites actively suppress the host immune system. This allows them to survive and reproduce without causing immediate death of the host. The mechanisms of immunosuppression are diverse (Roberts et al., 2013; Gunn & Pitt, 2022):

  • Polyclonal B-cell activation. In trypanosomiasis and some other infections, the parasite causes nonspecific activation of many B cells, leading to exhaustion of the immune system and production of “useless” antibodies not directed against the parasite.
  • Induction of regulatory T cells (Tregs). Helminths often stimulate the formation of Tregs, which suppress the activity of effector T cells. For example, filarial nematodes (for example, Litomosoides sigmodontis) maintain long-term infection by activating Tregs. If these cells are removed, the immune system begins to effectively destroy the parasite (Roberts et al., 2013).
  • Secretion of immunosuppressive molecules. Some parasites release substances that suppress the functions of macrophages and dendritic cells. For example, Fasciola hepatica releases antigens that induce expression of the SOCS3 gene, suppressing cytokine signaling pathways and reducing the ability of dendritic cells to present antigens to T cells (Roberts et al., 2013).

3. Masking

Parasites can “mask” themselves as host cells so that the immune system does not recognize them as foreign. The most striking example is Schistosoma (blood fluke). Adult schistosomes cover their surface with host antigens—for example, blood group antigens, MHC I proteins, IgG. Thus, the immune system “sees” only “self” and does not attack the parasite. In addition, schistosomes constantly shed their outer membrane (membranocalyx), which may contain bound antibodies, and replace it with a new one (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013).

4. Intracellular refuge

Many protozoan parasites live inside host cells, where they are inaccessible to antibodies. For example, Leishmania multiplies inside macrophages, Plasmodium—inside erythrocytes and hepatocytes, Toxoplasma—inside a wide variety of cells. The intracellular location protects them from humoral immunity, although cellular immunity (cytotoxic T cells) can recognize them. However, parasites often prevent the fusion of the phagosome with the lysosome or neutralize reactive oxygen species (Roberts et al., 2013).

5. Modulation of the immune response

Parasites can shift the balance of cytokines in their favor. For example, many helminths induce a strong Th2 response, which promotes their survival. Th2 cytokines (IL-4, IL-5, IL-13) activate eosinophils and mast cells, which are not always effective against large parasites, but at the same time suppress the Th1 response necessary for fighting intracellular pathogens. This can lead to reduced resistance to other infections (Roberts et al., 2013; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Why Is Immunity Against Parasites Often Incomplete?

Even with a powerful immune system, it is not always possible to completely get rid of a parasite. There are several reasons (Roberts et al., 2013; Gunn & Pitt, 2022):

1. Complexity of the life cycle. The immune response directed against one stage may not work against another. For example, in schistosomes, cercariae (larvae penetrating through the skin) and adult worms have different antigens.

2. Antigenic variation. As in trypanosomes, constant change of surface antigens does not allow the immune system to “lock on” to one variant.

3. Immunosuppression. The parasite actively suppresses the immune response, which does not allow the organism to completely destroy it.

4. Masking. The parasite becomes “invisible” to the immune system.

5. Premunition and concomitant immunity. In some cases, the organism becomes resistant to repeated infection but cannot get rid of an existing parasite. This phenomenon is called premunition (for example, in toxoplasmosis, Chagas disease, malaria) or concomitant immunity. In schistosomiasis, adult worms remain in the organism, but new larvae penetrating the skin are destroyed (Roberts et al., 2013).

Why Are Parasitic Diseases Often Chronic?

A chronic course is the result of the parasite’s evolutionary “strategy.” It is disadvantageous for a parasite to kill the host too quickly, as this would deprive it of a food source and the opportunity to spread. Therefore, many parasites strive for long-term coexistence with the host. They cause minimal damage that does not lead to immediate death, but at the same time successfully reproduce and spread (Roberts et al., 2013; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Examples of chronic parasitic diseases: malaria, schistosomiasis, leishmaniasis, trypanosomiasis, filariases, toxoplasmosis. All of them can last for years and decades, and sometimes for life. The immune system cannot completely destroy the parasite, but the parasite does not kill the host—a fragile equilibrium is established.

Thus, parasites are a unique group of pathogens that demonstrates remarkable adaptations to the host immune system. They use antigenic variation, immunosuppression, masking, intracellular refuge, and modulation of the immune response. As a result, immunity against parasites is often incomplete, and diseases take a chronic course. Understanding these mechanisms is necessary not only for developing effective methods of combating parasitic diseases but also for understanding the evolution of the host–parasite system as a whole.

In the next section, we will examine how this knowledge is applied in the agrosphere—from vaccination of agricultural animals to plant immunity and biological control of insect pests.

10. Immunity and the Agrosphere

We have completed an overview of the fundamental principles of immunology: from innate defense in invertebrates to the complex system of adaptive immunity in vertebrates, from parasite evasion mechanisms to the foundations of vaccination. Now let us connect this knowledge with practical aspects important for specialists in agriculture. The immune system is not only an object of fundamental science but also a key factor determining the success of animal husbandry, aquaculture, and even crop production (Pillay & Kutty, 2005; Scanes, 2020).

Why Is This Important for an Agronomist?

For a specialist in agriculture, understanding immunity has direct practical significance. The health of agricultural animals is the basis of their productivity: growth, weight gain, egg production, milk yield. Diseases lead to direct economic losses: death, reduced productivity, treatment costs, as well as trade restrictions during outbreaks of especially dangerous infections. Therefore, managing immunity is an integral part of modern agricultural production (Scanes, 2020; Pillay & Kutty, 2005).

Let us consider four key areas where knowledge about immunity finds practical application.

a) Vaccination of agricultural animals—the basis for preventing infectious diseases

Vaccination is the most effective and economically advantageous method of combating infectious diseases in animal husbandry. As we discussed in section 8, vaccines “teach” the immune system by stimulating the formation of memory cells without the risk of clinical disease. In veterinary medicine, this principle is used everywhere.

For example, in poultry farming, vaccination is routine practice. Chicks are vaccinated against Marek’s disease, Newcastle disease, infectious bronchitis, infectious bursal disease (Gumboro disease), and other dangerous viral diseases. Vaccines are administered both in ovo (into the egg on days 17–19 of incubation) and in the first days of the chick’s life. This prevents mass death of poultry and reduces the need for antibiotics (Scanes, 2020).

In fish farming, vaccination is also becoming standard. For salmonids, vaccines have been developed against furunculosis (Aeromonas salmonicida), vibriosis (Vibrio anguillarum), infectious pancreatic necrosis (IPN), and other diseases. Fish vaccination is carried out by injection, immersion, or orally (with feed). This reduces the use of antibiotics and increases production profitability (Pillay & Kutty, 2005; Stickney & Gatlin, 2022).

For cattle and pigs, vaccines have also been developed against anthrax, foot-and-mouth disease, classical swine fever, swine erysipelas, and many other infections. Vaccination is not only protection of individual animals but also the creation of herd immunity, which reduces circulation of the pathogen in the population (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

b) Plant immunity (analogy)

Although plants are not animals and do not have an adaptive immune system, they possess their own mechanisms of defense against pathogens. Understanding these mechanisms is useful for an agronomist, as it allows the development of plant protection strategies without excessive use of pesticides (Hasanuzzaman, 2019).

Plants possess innate immunity, which includes:

  • Physical barriers: cuticle, cell walls, waxy coating on leaves.
  • Chemical barriers: antimicrobial compounds (phytoalexins, phenolic compounds) synthesized in response to infection.
  • Systemic acquired resistance (SAR): after local infection, a plant can become resistant to a broad spectrum of pathogens in all tissues. This resembles immune memory in animals, although the mechanisms are completely different. SAR is triggered by signaling molecules such as salicylic acid and jasmonic acid (Hasanuzzaman, 2019).

Understanding these mechanisms allows the use of biological plant protection methods: for example, treating plants with elicitors (substances that trigger SAR) or using antagonist plants that release antimicrobial compounds. This reduces dependence on chemical pesticides and makes agriculture more sustainable (Hasanuzzaman, 2019).

c) Insect immune response to parasitoids—the basis of biological control

As we discussed in section 3, insects possess effective innate immunity, which includes phagocytosis, encapsulation, and melanization. These mechanisms play a key role in the interaction of insects with their natural enemies—parasitoids (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

Parasitoids are insects (most often wasps from the order Hymenoptera or flies from the order Diptera) whose larvae develop inside or on the body of the host, gradually killing it. However, the host insect is not defenseless: its immune system can encapsulate and melanize the egg or larva of the parasitoid, killing it (Gullan & Cranston, 2014; Straalen, 2023).

This interaction has important practical significance for biological control of pests. Many parasitoids are used in agriculture to combat insect pests. For example, ichneumon wasps of the genus Trichogramma lay eggs in the eggs of pest butterflies, destroying them. Understanding how the pest’s immune system responds to the parasitoid allows the selection of the most effective parasitoid strains and increases the success of biological control (Hasanuzzaman, 2019).

In addition, some parasitoids have developed mechanisms for suppressing host immunity. For example, they inject viruses or toxins into the host body that suppress encapsulation. Studying these mechanisms opens new possibilities for creating biopesticides and genetically modified organisms for pest control (Gullan & Cranston, 2014).

d) Immunity and disease resistance in aquaculture

Aquaculture is a rapidly growing branch of agriculture, and diseases cause enormous damage to it. Annual losses from diseases in aquaculture are estimated in billions of dollars (Stickney & Gatlin, 2022). Understanding the immunity of fish and invertebrates is critically important for the sustainable development of this industry.

Fish possess both innate and adaptive immunity, similar to terrestrial vertebrates. However, they have their own peculiarities. For example, fish antibodies are less diverse than those of mammals, and the immune response depends on water temperature. At low temperatures, the fish immune system works more slowly, making them more vulnerable to infections (Pillay & Kutty, 2005).

Invertebrates cultivated in aquaculture (shrimp, mollusks, crabs) rely exclusively on innate immunity. They have no antibodies or memory cells, so vaccination against viral diseases (for example, white spot syndrome in shrimp) is ineffective. Instead, management strategies are used: reducing stocking density, maintaining optimal water quality, using probiotics and immunostimulants (for example, β-glucans) to activate innate immunity (Stickney & Gatlin, 2022; Wickins & Lee, 2002).

Selection for disease resistance is also an important direction. For example, in salmon aquaculture, selection is conducted for fish resistant to infectious salmon anemia (ISA) and other viral diseases. In shrimp farming, lines resistant to white spot syndrome virus (WSSV) and other pathogens have been developed (Stickney & Gatlin, 2022; Wickins & Lee, 2002).

Thus, immunity is not only a fundamental biological discipline but also a field of knowledge with enormous practical significance for the agrosphere. Vaccination of animals, understanding plant immunity, using parasitoids for biological control, managing health in aquaculture—all of this is based on the principles we have discussed. Knowledge of these principles allows an agronomist to make informed decisions aimed at increasing productivity and sustainability of agricultural production.

In the next section, we will summarize the evolution of immunity and discuss why this system is an example of the evolution of complex systems.

11. Evolution of Immunity: Summary

We have traveled a long path from the simplest forms of defense in invertebrates to the most complex system of adaptive immunity in vertebrates. It is time to summarize and generalize the main milestones in the evolution of the immune system, as well as to understand why this system is a striking example of the evolution of complex biological systems.

Innate Immunity—Ancient, Present in All Animals

Innate immunity is the foundation upon which all defense of the organism is built. Its mechanisms—phagocytosis, antimicrobial peptides, the complement system, encapsulation, and melanization—are found in very different groups of animals, from sponges and cnidarians to insects, mollusks, annelids, and vertebrates (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022). This means that innate immunity arose very early in the evolution of multicellular organisms and proved so effective that it persisted with virtually no fundamental changes in all modern animals.

Innate immunity works immediately, without requiring time for recognition and activation. It recognizes common, conserved molecular structures characteristic of entire groups of pathogens (PAMPs) and launches a universal response. That is why innate immunity is present in all animals—it is indispensable for a rapid response to infection (Pough et al., 2013; Hickman et al., 2004).

Adaptive Immunity—Evolutionarily Young, Present Only in Vertebrates

Adaptive immunity in the classical sense—with B and T lymphocytes, antibodies, and V(D)J recombination—is characteristic only of jawed vertebrates (Gnathostomata). This event occurred approximately 500 million years ago, in the early Paleozoic, when the first jawed fishes began to explore new ecological niches (Pough et al., 2013).

The key molecular mechanism that made the appearance of adaptive immunity possible was V(D)J recombination—a unique process allowing millions, and possibly billions, of different variants of antibodies and T-cell receptors to be created from a limited number of genes. This process became possible thanks to RAG genes, which originated from “domesticated” transposons (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013).

Adaptive immunity provided vertebrates with an enormous advantage: high specificity, immune memory, and the ability to fight intracellular pathogens. However, it requires time to develop and is energetically expensive, which limits its distribution to those groups that have sufficient resources to maintain it (Hickman et al., 2004; Pough et al., 2013).

Alternative Solutions: VLR in Jawless Vertebrates

The discovery of the VLR system in lampreys and hagfish showed that adaptive immunity is not the only possible path to highly specific defense. Jawless vertebrates independently acquired a system based on somatic recombination of leucine-rich repeats (LRRs), which provides specific recognition of pathogens and formation of immune memory but uses completely different molecular tools (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

This is a striking example of convergent evolution—a process in which different groups of organisms independently acquire similar traits to solve the same problem. Nature found two different solutions to the problem of adaptive immunity, and both proved effective. Studying the VLR system not only expands our knowledge of the evolution of immunity but also opens new prospects for practical application in medicine and veterinary science (Pough et al., 2013; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Why Is the Immune System an Example of the Evolution of Complex Systems?

The immune system is a brilliant example of how evolution can create complex, multilevel systems using relatively simple “building blocks.” Here are several key principles that the evolution of immunity illustrates:

1. Gradualism. The immune system did not arise “from scratch.” It formed through the gradual addition of new mechanisms to already existing ones. Innate immunity is the ancient foundation; adaptive immunity is a superstructure that appeared later and used some already existing molecular tools (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

2. Co-option (repurposing). RAG genes originated from transposons—“jumping genes” that initially performed completely different functions. Evolution “repurposed” them to create a system for generating receptor diversity. This is a striking example of co-option—using existing structures for new purposes (Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Roberts et al., 2013).

3. Convergence. The VLR system of jawless vertebrates and the V(D)J system of jawed vertebrates are independent solutions to one problem. Evolution can lead to the same functional result by different paths (Pough et al., 2013).

4. Compromise. Adaptive immunity provides high specificity and memory but requires time and energy. Innate immunity is fast and economical but less specific. These two systems complement each other, providing optimal protection at minimal cost (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

5. Coevolution with pathogens. The immune system evolves in response to pathogen adaptations, and pathogens, in turn, evolve in response to host immune mechanisms. This is an “arms race” that has lasted millions of years and leads to the appearance of increasingly complex mechanisms on both sides (Roberts et al., 2013).

Why Is Understanding the Evolution of Immunity Important for Medicine and Veterinary Science?

Understanding the evolution of immunity has enormous practical significance. It allows us to:

  • Develop new vaccines. Knowledge of the mechanisms of V(D)J recombination and the formation of immune memory underlies the creation of vaccines—from traditional to modern mRNA vaccines (Gunn & Pitt, 2022).
  • Combat pathogens that evade the immune response. Understanding how parasites mask themselves, suppress immunity, or change antigens helps develop strategies to combat them (Roberts et al., 2013).
  • Improve the health of agricultural animals. Vaccination, selection for disease resistance, and the use of immunostimulants—all of this is based on knowledge of immunology (Scanes, 2020; Pillay & Kutty, 2005).
  • Understand human evolution. The immune system is the result of long evolution, and studying it helps understand how our ancestors adapted to pathogens and how these adaptations affect our health today (Pough et al., 2013).

Thus, the evolution of immunity is a story about how nature created one of the most complex and effective defense systems using gradual changes, co-option of existing molecules, convergent solutions, and constant coevolution with pathogens. The immune system is an example of the evolution of complex systems that inspires scientists to develop new methods of treatment and disease prevention.

In the next, final section, we will summarize the entire module “Animal Morphology and Physiology” and discuss how all organ systems work as a unified whole.

12. Summary of the Module “Animal Morphology and Physiology”

We have come to the completion of our module “Animal Morphology and Physiology.” Throughout this course, we have consistently examined the structure and functions of the main organ systems of animals: integuments, skeleton and musculature, digestion, respiration, circulation, excretion, the nervous system, sensory organs, the endocrine system, and finally, the immune system. It is time to look back and see the overall picture: how all these systems work together, forming a single, integrated organism (Hickman et al., 2004; Pough et al., 2013).

All Organ Systems Work as a Unified Whole

The organism of an animal is not merely the sum of individual organs and systems. It is an integrated, self-regulating system in which each component depends on the others and influences them. Let us consider several examples of such integration (Hickman et al., 2004; Pough et al., 2013).

Digestion and metabolism. The digestive system breaks down food into simple molecules, which are then absorbed into the blood. The circulatory system transports these nutrients to all cells of the body. The respiratory system provides the supply of oxygen necessary for the oxidation of nutrients and the release of energy. The excretory system removes metabolic products. The endocrine system regulates the rate of these processes with the help of hormones such as insulin and glucagon, which control blood glucose levels (Hickman et al., 2004; Scanes, 2020).

Movement and coordination. The skeleton and musculature provide movement and support. However, coordinated work of muscles requires the nervous system, which transmits signals from the brain and spinal cord to the muscles. Sensory organs collect information from the external environment (vision, hearing, smell, touch), which is processed by the nervous system and used to make decisions about movement. The endocrine system modulates these processes by influencing the excitability of the nervous system and muscle tone (Hickman et al., 2004; Pough et al., 2013).

Homeostasis and immunity. All organ systems work together to maintain the constancy of the internal environment—homeostasis. For example, the respiratory and circulatory systems regulate the level of oxygen and carbon dioxide, the excretory system regulates water–salt balance and pH, and the endocrine system regulates hormone levels. The immune system, which we have examined in detail, protects the organism from pathogens that can disrupt the work of any of these systems. In turn, the normal functioning of all systems is necessary for the effective work of the immune system (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022).

Why Is Understanding Morphology and Physiology Necessary for Understanding Ecology, Behavior, Evolution, and Practical Aspects of Animal Biology?

Knowledge of animal morphology and physiology is the foundation upon which all other biological disciplines are built (Pough et al., 2013; Hickman et al., 2004).

Ecology. Understanding how animals obtain energy, breathe, regulate body temperature, and excrete waste allows us to explain their distribution in various environments. For example, fish can live in water thanks to gills, which effectively extract oxygen from water; terrestrial animals have lungs, which allow them to breathe atmospheric air. The ability to regulate body temperature (endothermy in birds and mammals) allows them to occupy cold and hot environments where ectothermic animals would not survive (Pough et al., 2013).

Behavior. Animal behavior is largely determined by their physiology. For example, migrations of birds and fish are associated with changes in photoperiod and hormonal status. Feeding behavior depends on the feeling of hunger, which is regulated by hormones and the level of nutrients in the blood. Reproductive behavior is controlled by sex hormones. Understanding the physiological mechanisms of behavior allows us to explain why animals behave in one way or another (Hickman et al., 2004; Pough et al., 2013).

Evolution. Morphological and physiological adaptations are the result of natural selection. For example, the appearance of jaws in vertebrates allowed them to transition from filtration to active predation. The appearance of adaptive immunity allowed vertebrates to effectively fight pathogens and increase lifespan. Understanding the evolution of organ systems allows us to reconstruct the history of life on Earth and understand how the modern diversity of animals arose (Pough et al., 2013; Hickman et al., 2004).

Practical aspects. In agriculture, aquaculture, veterinary medicine, and medicine, knowledge about animal morphology and physiology has direct practical application. For example, understanding digestive physiology allows optimal feed rations to be formulated for agricultural animals. Knowledge of the endocrine regulation of growth and reproduction is used to manage productivity. Understanding the immune system underlies vaccination and disease control. Understanding the physiology of stress allows improving animal housing conditions and reducing losses (Scanes, 2020; Pillay & Kutty, 2005; Stickney & Gatlin, 2022).

Conclusion

The immune system is only one of many organ systems, but it clearly demonstrates the main principles we have considered throughout the entire module: integration, regulation, adaptation, and evolution. Innate immunity is an ancient, universal defense present in all animals. Adaptive immunity is an evolutionarily young system characteristic only of vertebrates. Alternative solutions, such as the VLR system of jawless vertebrates, show that evolution can create different tools to solve one problem. The immune system is an example of the evolution of complex systems, and understanding it is of enormous importance for medicine, veterinary science, and agriculture (Hickman et al., 2004; Gunn & Pitt, 2022; Pough et al., 2013).

Thus, animal morphology and physiology are not merely a set of facts about the structure and functions of organs. They are the key to understanding how animals interact with their environment, how they evolved, and how we can use this knowledge to improve human and animal life. Understanding these principles is necessary for every biologist, veterinarian, agronomist, and specialist in agriculture.

References

  1. (2022). ‘Diseases and Parasites of Aquaculture Species’, in Stickney, R.R., III, D.M.G. (ed.) Aquaculture. GB: CABI, 164-191. doi: 10.1079/9781800621145.0005
  2. Gosling, Elizabeth (2015). ‘Diseases and parasites’, in Marine Bivalve Molluscs. West Sussex, UK: Wiley Blackwell, pp. 429-477.
  3. Gullan, P.J., Cranston, P.S. (2014). ‘Internal anatomy and physiology’, in The Insects. An Outline of Entomology. West Sussex, UK: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 56-94.
  4. Helfman, G.S., Collette, B.B., Facey, D.E., Bowen, B.W. (2009). ‘Homeostasis’, in The Diversity of Fishes. Biology, Evolution, and Ecology. West Sussex, UK: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 91-110.
  5. Helfman, G.S., Collette, B.B., Facey, D.E., Bowen, B.W. (2009). ‘Living Representatives of Primitive Fishes’, in The Diversity of Fishes. Biology, Evolution, and Ecology. West Sussex, UK: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 231-260.
  6. Helfman, G.S., Collette, B.B., Facey, D.E., Bowen, B.W. (2009). ‘“A History of Fishes”’, in The Diversity of Fishes. Biology, Evolution, and Ecology. West Sussex, UK: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 167-204.
  7. Hickman, C.R. Jr., Roberts, L.S., Larson, Allan, I’Anson, H. (2004). ‘Immunity’, in Integrated Principles of Zoology. New York, NY: Higher Education, pp. 738-751.
  8. Khan, S.Mahmood, Ali, Sajid, Nawaz, Aamir, Bukhari, S.AsadH., Ejaz, Shaghef, Ahmad, Shakeel (2019). ‘Integrated Pest and Disease Management for Better Agronomic Crop Production’, in Agronomic Crops. Singapore: Springer Singapore, 385-428. doi: 10.1007/978-981-32-9783-8_19
  9. Pillay, T.V.R., Kutty, M.N. (2005). ‘Health and Diseases’, in Aquaculture. Principles and Practices. Oxford, UK: Blackwell Publishing, pp. 201-245.
  10. Pough, F.Harvey, Janis, C.M., Heiser, J.B. (2013). ‘Early Vertebrates: Jawless Vertebrates and the Origin of Jawed Vertebrates’, in Vertebrate Life. Glenview, IL: Pearson, pp. 47-70.
  11. Pough, F.Harvey, Janis, C.M., Heiser, J.B. (2013). ‘Vertebrate Relationships and Basic Structure’, in Vertebrate Life. Glenview, IL: Pearson, pp. 19-46.
  12. Roberts, L.S., Janovy, J. Jr., Nadler, Steve (2013). ‘Basic Principles and Concepts II: Immunology and Pathology’, in Foundations of Parasitology. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, pp. 23-40.
  13. Roberts, L.S., Janovy, J. Jr., Nadler, Steve (2013). ‘Parasitic Crustaceans’, in Foundations of Parasitology. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, pp. 513-534.
  14. Roberts, L.S., Janovy, J. Jr., Nadler, Steve (2013). ‘Phylum Acanthocephala: Thorny-Headed Worms’, in Foundations of Parasitology. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, pp. 473-488.
  15. Roberts, L.S., Janovy, J. Jr., Nadler, Steve (2013). ‘Phylum Arthropoda: Form, Function, and Classification’, in Foundations of Parasitology. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, pp. 489-512.
  16. Scanes, C.G., Christensen, K.D. (2020). ‘Diseases and Health of Poultry’, in Poultry Science. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press, pp. 199-226.
  17. Wickins, J.F., Daniel O’C. Lee (2002). ‘Biology’, in Crustacean Farming. Ranching and Culture. Ames, Iowa: Blackwell Science, pp. 9-34.
  18. vanStraalen, N.M. (2023). ‘Physiological Adaptation and Microbial Interactions’, in Soil Invertebrates. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 223-294. doi: 10.1201/9780429172830-6